Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:

Title: Is “Vijñaptimātra” ontological or epistemological idealism?
Authors: 楊志常
Contributors: 宗教博三
Keywords: Vijñaptimātra;Ontological idealism/Epistemological idealism;Vimśatikāvijñaptimātratāsiddhi;Triṃśikāvijñaptimātratā;Cheng Wei Shi Lun (CWSL);Sandhinirmocanasūtra
Date: 2016-06
Issue Date: 2018-08-28 10:38:48 (UTC+8)
Abstract: There has been no academic agreement on whether “Vijñaptimātra”(Consciousness-only) should be understood to advocate ontological
idealism or epistemological idealism. What is amusing and confusing is that there are several occasions that both sides of the debate are reading same texts or even referring to the same paragraph but interpreting it in totally different way. This article is intended to draw attention to those texts and paragraphs from Vimśatikāvijñaptimātratāsiddhi, Triṃśikāvijñaptimātratā, Cheng Wei Shi Lun (CWSL), Sandhinirmocanasūtra, Yogācārabhūmi, Mahāyāna-samgraha where both sides of the debate confront each other with their competing arguments. The purpose is to understand better where the possible differences are coming from in the hope to reduce some confusion/bias and to find common denominator if any. Discussion finds the debates might be attributed to several factors: the deep-rooted equivocal relationship between cosmology and psychology in Buddhist tradition; different translations of the key term “vijñānapariṇāma”; how to understand the generalization from meditation practice experience to ordinary experience; and what to expect regarding the coherence among Yogācāra texts and within Yogācāra lineage and whether and where the interoperation should be applied. Last, it is suggested that whether ontological idealist theory is making perfect sense and whether “Vijñaptimātra” be understood as ontological idealism should be decoupled and addressed as different topics.
Relation: 正觀, No.77, pp.113-166
Data Type: article
Appears in Collections:[宗教研究所] 期刊論文

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat
113-166.pdf607KbAdobe PDF181View/Open

All items in 學術集成 are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.

社群 sharing