Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:

Title: 不情願的專業主義:從普天間基地問題探討日本民主黨政權決策過程
Other Titles: Reluctant Professionalism: The Decision Making Process of the DPJ Government on the MCAS Futenma Issue
Authors: 李世暉
Li, Shih-Hui
Contributors: 政大日本研究碩士學位學程
Keywords: 多元主義;專業主義;日本民主黨;普天間基地;決策過程
Democratic Party of Japan;Decision-making Process;Professionalism;Pluralism;Marine Corps Air Station MCAS Futenma
Date: 2012-12
Issue Date: 2013-06-07 10:41:44 (UTC+8)
Abstract: 2009年9月16日成立的日本民主黨政權,以落實其「政權公約」為政府主要的施政方針。觀察民主黨歷年的政權公約發現,日本行政體制的改革一直是該黨政權公約的主要內容,而其核心主張即是建立一「擺脫官僚依賴」的決策機制,並讓國民的多元意見能夠在此一機制內獲得反映。民主黨首任首相鳩山由紀夫,即以「脫官僚」(擺脫依賴官僚)與「市民主體」(國民意見優先)的理念思維,思考「普天間基地遷移」的議題。此一影響重大的議題有兩大重要特徵:第一,排除專業官僚的決策參與;第二,首相官邸主導決策。在9個月的決策過程中,民主黨政權內部的多元主義決策思維扮演關鍵角色,與擁有專業知識、熟習決策流程的官僚之間,呈現對抗的態勢。鳩山由紀夫排除專業官僚的結果,導致決策的挫敗,也使得繼任的菅直人與野田佳彥首相不得不重新借重官僚的專業。此一轉變,與過去民主黨政權公約的內容相左,但卻是民主黨不得不與政治現實進行的妥協方案,可稱之為「不情願的專業主義」。
After coming to power on September 16, 2009, the key priority for theDemocratic Party of Japan (DPJ) government was to enforce its manifesto, whichaimed to weaken bureaucrats and produce a more pluralistic decision makingmechanism. Based on these principles, Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama reviewedthe issue of the relocation of Marine Corps Air Station Futenma (MCAS Futenma).Two key factors were at work: first, wresting control of the decision making processfrom professional bureaucrats, and, second, giving the Cabinet Office predominancein the policy domain. During the nine-month period of the Hatoyama Cabinet,pluralist decision-making dominated, resulting in conflict with the professionalizedbureaucracy. However, exclusion of bureaucrats from decision-making led to policyfailure. As a result, the subsequent Kan and Noda premierships were forced to returnto the bureaucratic policy-making system. This change contradicted DPJ manifestoprinciples, and was regarded as a compromise in the face of political reality. This compromise might be labeled as “reluctant professionalism.”
Relation: 政治科學論叢, 54, 37-70
Data Type: article
Appears in Collections:[日本研究學位學程] 期刊論文

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat

All items in 學術集成 are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.

社群 sharing