學術產出-學位論文
文章檢視/開啟
書目匯出
-
題名 技術能力與技術引進績效相關之研究 作者 林明杰 貢獻者 劉水深<br>賴士葆
林明杰日期 1992 上傳時間 10-五月-2016 18:51:59 (UTC+8) 摘要 在目前我國產業普遍面臨勞工短缺、匯率升值等不利的投資環境下，企業欲以產業昇級擺脫經營困境的最佳的方式，即是運由技術引進、整合、再發展為自有技術、以提昇本身基礎研究能力等過程，逐漸提昇技術水準，進而達成以技術進步強化競爭能力提昇經營績效以擺脫目前的困境。\n本研究初期經由相關文獻探討、及對企業的深度訪談發現，技術接受者本身技術能力為影響我國企業技術引進績效最重要的關鍵因素，因此整合過去學者的研究，建立技術能力與技術引進績效相關之研究架構，選擇自民國七十五年至七十九年底，在經濟部投資審議委員會登錄之合作案件，並以該期間中佔我國技術引進項目31.6%的電子電機業為母體，實證企業技術能力與技術引進績效間之關\n係，並分別探討引進技術特性、技術引進管理模式等中介變數對技術能力與引進績效間之影響。\n本研究對企業技術能力的衡量，除了參照Sharif、及賴士葆的分類外、並舉行國內實務專家座談等綜合後，將技術能力區分為1 .經驗能力2. 經費能力3 .設備能力 4 .產出能力5 .資訊能力6. 管理談判能力;等六個衡量構面。 問時以分析層級法(A H P )獲得各衡量構面應有的權重，以此計算各別企業在技術引進前之技術能力。\n本研究所使用的分析方法包括: 次數分配、單因子變異數分析、因素分析、集群分析、兩因子變異數分析、區別分析及交叉分析等。\n本研究發現技術引進者之技術能力與引進:績效間之關係，同時發現當技術接受者技術能力不足時，應、如何依本身狀況，挑選合適的技術引進，或在引進過程中調整管理模式，以提昇技術引進績效。 參考文獻 1中文部份\n－－－，"技術合作條例"，經濟部投資處印行，民國75年4月。\n───，"中華民國科學技術年鑑(民國七十八年)，行政院國家科學\n委員會編印，民國79年9月出版。\n───，經濟部投資審議委員會，"中華民國設術合作統計月報”，民\n國七十九年八月出版。\n－──"，經濟部產業技術發展概要79年度"，民國88年2月，\n毛倩文我國廠商國際技術進成敗關鍵因素之研究..國立政治大學\n國際貿易研究所未出版碩士論文，民國88年1月。\n王志剛，"我國工業科技移轉之現況"，自由化下的科技發展與科技政\n策學術研討會論文集，民國76年9月26日。\n王連常福"技術引進與我國工業結構之改變"，經濟研究，22，民國\n68年7月。\n司徒達賢、李仁芳、吳忠華等合著，企業概論，教育部空中教學委員\n會，民國74年8月初版。\n李慶成，"多國籍企業與技術移轉之關係"，政治大學企業管理研究所\n未出版碩士論文，民國71年6月。\n杜震華，"研究發展對生產與貿易之效果"，中華民國科技管理學會，中\n華民國1991科技管理研討會為文集，民國80年10月。\n林由，"我國產業發展與研發體系之變遷"經濟部科技顧問室－產業\n科技研究發展管理論文集，民國79年6月。\n林明杰，"研究發展與製造之介面研究，國立政治大學企業管理研究\n所，未出版碩士論文，民國77年6月。\n林鴻鈞，"台灣機械業技術引進的成本與效益"，台銀季刊，33(3)，民\n國71年9月。\n周榮堅，"技術移轉決策因素研究"，國立政治大學企業管理研究所未\n出版碩士論文，民國74年6月。\n吳家馨，"生產力指揮研究報告"，中國生產力中心，民國75年6月。\n青柳全原著，黃南斗、葉錦堂譯，"新產品開發實務指南?，台華工商\n圖書出版公司，民76年8月初版。\n陳定園、徐金水，”中外技術合作之有效途徑(條件與程序)”，台北:\n工業技術研究院金屬研究院，民國67年6月。\n許士軍，管理學，東華書書，民國71年3月二版。\n湯明哲，"策略規劃與技術創新的介面”，經濟部科技顧問室:產業科\n技研究發展管理論文集，民圍79年6月14日。\n黃家齊，"技術引進成效影響因素之研究”，私立中原大學企業管理研\n究所未出版碩士論文，民國79年6月。\n曾建動，”技術移轉對產品開發活動之影響"，國立政治大學企業管理\n研究所未出版碩士論文，民國73年6月。\n詹文瑛，日本政府出資之研究開發與成果移轉探討，工業投術研究院\n工業經濟研究中心，民國79年3月出版。\n蔡敦浩，"科技變遷趨勢與企業科技創新策酪-新興工業化國家的觀點\n“，經濟部科技顧問室:產業科技研究發展管理論文集，民國79年6月\n蔡敦浩，”日本企業科技管理特性初探”，中華民國科技管理學會，中華\n民國1991科技管理研討會論文集。民間88年10月。\n齊世基，刊機械工業的技術移轉\n鄭優， ”我國工業科技移轉之研究:影響技術引進成效因素之探討"，\n國立政治大學企業管理研究所未出版碩士論文，民國78年6月。\n賴士葆，"企業技術特性與新產品發展績效相關之研究”，管理評論：\n國立政治大學企管研究所出版，民國76年7月。\n賴士葆、林明杰， ”研究發展與製造兩部門互動之研究"，管理評論，\n國立政治大學企管研究所:光華管理策進基金會圖書部發行，民國\n78年7月。\n賴士葆，"研究發展/行銷/製造三部門互動與新產品發展績效相關之\n研究"，華泰書局，民國79年6月。\n賴士葆，”企業技術引進方式與其績效間相關之研究”，國立政治大學\n企管研究所，民國79年7月。\n賴榮仁，"美、日在台企業管理技術移轉之研究”，國立政治大學企業\n管理研究所未出版博士論文，民國75年1月。\n薛琦& Majumder, B.”內生技術變動與經濟發展”，中國經濟學會論文\n集，民國67年12月。\n薛琦，"我國電子電器製造業技術合作實施成果調查報告"，”我國機械\n儀器製造業技術合作實施成果調查報告"，"我國化學業技術合作實\n路成果調查報告”，"我國基本金屬及金屬製品製造業技術合作實施\n成果調查報告，經濟部投資審議委員會，民國69年-民國72年。\n薛琦，(1987)，"我國產業的技術移轉與技術發展"，中美技術合作作研\n究會、工商時報聯合舉辦之，自由化下的科技發展與科技政策學術\n研討會，民國76年9月26日。\n薛琦，"技術引進的途徑與效益”，中國論壇，253期，民76年。\n謝安田，企業研究方法，作者自印，民國72年。\n蕭峰雄，”當前推動技術移轉之課題”中美技術季刊，29(2)，民國73\n年6月。\n蕭峰雄、周皎瑜，"我國財團法人研究機構技術移轉之研究-積體電路\n與機器人之個案研究”，作者未發表論文，民74年。\n嚴永晃，"技術合作三十年的省思"，經濟雜誌，34，民國76年2月。\n二、英文部份\nAbernathy, W. J. & Utterback, J.M. " Dynamic Model of Process\nand Product Innovation ", Omega, 3(6),1975, pp.639-657.\nAuster, E.R. "International Corporate Linkages: Dynamic Forms\nIn Changing Environments", Columbia Jrnl of World Business,\n22(2), Summer 1987, pp.3-6.\nArnoni. Kossik. Peavy(1987), "Transfer Technology Successfully\n" Hydrocarbon Processing, 66(18). Oct.1987, pp.55-66.\nBae. Zongtae & Jinjoo Lee , "Technology Development Patterns\nof Small and Medium Sized Companies in the Korean Machinery\nIndustry " Technovation, 4, 1986, pp.279-296.\nBaker, H.R.; Green, S.G.; & Bean, A.S. "The need for Strategic\nBalance in R&D Project Portfolios", Research Mgmt, Mar-Apr.,\n1986. pp.38-43.\nBaranson, J. "Transfer of Technical Knowledge by International\nCorporations to Developing Economics", AER 1966, P.259.\nBarbiroli, G.,"A New Method to evaluate the Special and Global\nAdvantage of a Technology", Technovation, 18(2). i4ar.1998,\npp.73-93.\nBaron, S, "Overcoming Barriers to Technology Transfer", Rese-\n-arch Technology mgmt, Jan-Feb 1998, pp.38-43.\nBarton, D.L., "Implementation as Mutual Adaptation of Techno-\nlogy and Organization", Research Policy, (17),1988, pp.251-267.\nBrown, M.A. & Berry, L.G. "Guidelines for Successfully Tra-\nnsferring Government-Sponsored Innovations", Research Policy\n20(1991), pp.121-143.\nBylinsky, G. "Turning R&D into Real Products", Fortune, 122\n(1), Ju1.2 1990, pp.72-77.\nChakrabarti, A.K. & Souder, W.E. "Technology Innovation and\nPerformance in Corporate Mergers: A Managerial Evaluation"\n,Technovation, 6, 1987, pp.103-114.\nChanaron , J. J. & Perrin, J. "The Transfer of Research, Deve-\n-lopment and Design to Developing Countries", Futures, Oct.\n1987, pp.503-512.\nCooper, R.G. "The Strategy Performance Link in Product Inno-\nvation ", R&D Management, 14-4. pp. 247-259.\nCutler, W. G. "Acquiring Technology From Outside", Research-Technology\nmgrnt, May-Jun 1991, pp.11-18.\n( Daft, R.L. & Lengel, R.H. "Organizational Information Requi-\nrements, Media Richness and Structural Design", Management\nScience, 32-5, May 1985, pp.554-571.\nDess, G.G. & Robinson, R.B. "Measuring Organizational Perfo-\n-rmance In the Absence of Objective Measures: The Case of\nPrivetely-Held Firm and Conglomerate Business Unit", Stra-\ntegic Mgmt Jrnl. ,5, 1984.\nDierdonck, R. Van "The Manufacturing/Design Interface", R&D\nManagement, 20 (3), 1990, pp. 203-209.\nDixon, J.R. & Duffey M.R. “The Neglect of Engineering Design\n“, Cal. Mgmt Review, Winter 1998, pp.9-23.\nDjeflat, A. "The Management of Technology Transfer: Views and\nExperiences of Developing Countries", Int. Jrnl. Technology\nManagement. 3-1/2, 1988, pp.149-165.\nDoll, W. J. & Torkzadeh, G. "The Measurement of End-User Compu-\nting Satisification", MIS Quarterly, 12(2), June 1988. pp.\n258-273.\nDamar, E.D. "On the Measurement of Technological Change", Eco-\nnomics Jrnl, 1961, pp.789-714.\nFagerberg, J. "A Technology Gap Approach to Why Growth Rates\nDiffer", Research Policy 16(1987), pp.87-99\nFrair, J. & Horwitch, M. "The Emergence of Technology Strategy\nIf, Technology in the Modern Corporation - A Strategic Pers-\npective, ed by Mel Horwitch, N Y: Pergamon Press Inc., 1986.\nGalbraith, C.S. "Transferring Core Manufacturing Technologies\nin High-Technology Firms", Cal. Mgmt Review, Summer 1990,\npp.56-78.\nGee, S. "The Role of Technology Transfer in Innovation", Re-\nsearch mgmt, Nov. 1974, PP.\nGerstenfield, A. "Effective management of Research and Deve-\n-lopment, Reading Mass. Addison-Wesley Pub. Co., 1978, pp41.\nGodkin, L. "Problems and Practicalities of Technology Transfer\n: A Survey of the Literature", International Jornal of Tech-\nnology Management, 3(5), 1988. pp.587-683.\nGupta, A.K. et al. "Managing the R&D-Marketing Interface"\nResearch Mgmt, 38(2), Mar/Apr 1987, pp.38-43.\nGupta, A.K. & Wilemon D.L. "Accelerating the Development of\nTechnology-Based Hew Products", Cal. Mgmt Review, Winter\n1998, pp.24-44.\nHabibie, B.J. "Sophisticated Technologies: Taking Root in De-\nveloping Countries~, International Jrnl of Technology Mgmt\n.,5(5),1990, pp.489-497.\nHakam, A.N. & Chang. Z. Y. "Patterns of Technology Transfer in\nSingapore:The Case of the Electronics and Computer Industry\n", Int. J. Technology Management, 3-1/2,1988, pp.181-188.\nHarvey, E. II Technology and The Structure of Organizations",\nAmerican Socialogical Review, 33, 1968, pp.247-259.\nHayes R.H. and Wheelwright S.C., "Restoring our Competitive\nEdge", 台北,華泰書局翻印,民國75年。\nHickson, D.J.; Pugh, D.S.; Pheysey, D.C. "Operations Techno-\nlogy and Organization Structure: An Empirical Reappraisal\n", Administrative Science Quarterly, Sep.1969, p.378.\nHendryx, S.R. "Implementation of a Technology Transfer Joint\nVenture in The People`s Republic of China: A Management\nPerspective”, Columbia Jrnl of World Business, 21(1),Spring\n1986, pp.57-66.\nJohnson, H.G. "Technology and Economic Independence", N Y:St.\nMartin`s Press for Trade Policy Research Center of London\n, 1976.\nKast, F. E. & Rosenzweig, J.E. "Organization & management: A\nsystem and Con tangency Approach",台北:淡江書局,民國74年\n8月一版, pp. 208-210.\nKeller, R.T. & Chinta, R.R. "International technology transfer\n: Strategies for Success", Academy of management Executive,\n4-2, May.199B, pp.33-43.\nKerlinger, F.N. "Foundations of Behavior Research", 3rd./ed.,\nNew York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 1986, p.443.\nKojima, Kiyoshi, "Transfer of Technology to Developing Coun-\n-tries-Japanese Type Versus American Type", Hitotsbubashi\nJrnl of Economics, 17(2), Feb.1977, pp.1-14.\nKokubo, A. "Japan`s R&D Managers Confront the Challenge of\nHigh Tech", R&D Magazine, 32(6), Jun. 199B, pp.83-86.\nKrishna, E.M. & Rao, C.P. "Is US High Technology High Enough\n", Columbia Jrnl of World Business, 21(2), Summer 1986, pp.\n47-54.\nKuzuets, S. "Modern Economic Growth, Rate Structure and Spread\n" , New Haven, Yale Univ. Press, 1965.\nLandau, R. "Harnessing Innovation for Growth", Chemical Engi-\n-neerlng Progress, 84(7), Jul. 1988, pp.31-42.\nLasserre, P. "Selecting a Foreign Partner for Technology Tra-\n-nsfer", Long Range Planning, 17(6), 1984, pp.43-49.\nLefebvre, L.A.; Harvey, J. and Lefebvre, E. " Technological\nExperience and the Technology Adoption In Small Manufactu-\n-ring Firms", R&D Mgmt, 21(3),1991, pp.241-249.\nLeroy, G.P. "Transfer of Developing Economics `Within the Mu-\n-ltinational Enterprise", 1978\nLin, Yeo, " Technology Change: A Microeconomic Study of the\nCRT-Relate consumer electronics Industry in Taiwan, U. of\nSan Diego, (1987),pp9B7-921.\nMadeuf, B. "International Technology Transfers and Internati-\nonal Technology Payments: Definitions, Measurement and\nFirms t Behaviour", Research Po 1 icy, 13 (1984), pp.125-1413.\nMadu C.N. "Transferring Technology to Developing Countries-Critical\nFactors for Sucess", Long Range Planning, 22(4),\n1989, pp.115-124.\nMadu, C.N. "Prescriptive Framework for the Transfer of Appro-\npriate Technology", Futures, Hov. 19913, pp.932-9513.\nMansour, M.B.; Hawkin, R.G.; & Prasad, A.J. "Definitional Issues\nin Technology Transfer: Channels, Mechanisms and Resources",\nTechnology Transfer and Development, 1981, p.l-l13.\nMaidique, M.A. & Patch, P. "Cooperate Strategy and Technological\nPolicy", in Tushman & Moore ed., Reading in the Management of\nInnovation, (Pitman: 1982).\nMajor, J.D. "Some Practical Intellectual Property Aspects of\nTechnology Transfer H\n, International Jrnl of Technology Mgmt\n,3(1/2),1988, pp.43-49.\nMansfield, E. "International Technology Transfer Resource\nRequirements and Policies", American Economic Association.\n68(2), May. 1975, pp.372-376.\nMartin, M.J.C. "Managing Technological Innovation and Enter-\n-preneuership", Reston, Virginia, Reston Publishing Co., Inc\n. 1984 , pp235.\nMeyer, A.D. "Tech Talk: How Managers Are Stimulating Global\nR&D Communication", Sloan Mgmt Review, Spring 1991, pp.49-\n58.\nMeyer, M.H. & Robert, E.B. "Focusing Product Technology for\nCorporate Growth", Sloan Mgmt Review, Summer 1988, pp.7-16.\nMitchell, W. "Using Academic Technology: Transfer Methods &\nLicensing Incidence in the Commercialization of American\nDiagnostic Imaging Equipment Research, 1954-1988 " , Research\nPolicy, 20(1991), pp.203-216 .\nMorbey, G. K. "R&D Expenditures and Profit Growth", Research\nTechnology Management, 32(3), May/Jun 1989, PP.20-23.\nMoriarty, R.T. & Kosnik, T.J. "High-Tech Marketing: Concepts,\nContinuity, and Change", Sloan Mgmt Review, Summer 1989, p.7\nOliva, T.A. "Information and Profitability Estimates: Modell\n-ing the Firm`s Decision to Adopt a New Technology", Mgmt\nScience, 37(5), May 1991, pp.687-623.\nPerrino, A.C. Tipping, J.W. "Global Management of Technology",\nResearch technology management, 32(3), May/Jun. 1989, pp.12-19 .\nPorter, M.E. "Competitive Advantage", New York: Free Press,\n1985, p.37.\nPrasad, S.B. "Technology Transfer: The Approach of a Dutch\nMultinational", Technovation, 4(1986), pp.3-15.\nQuinn, J.B. "Technology Transfer by Multinational Companies",\nHBR, Nov-Dec 1969.\nOunjian, M.L. & Carne, E.B. (1987) , .. A Study of the Factors\nWhich Affect Technology Transfer in a Multilocation Multi-Business\nUnit Corporation", IEEE Transactions on Engineering\nManagement, Vol.EM-34,H0.3, August, 1987, pp.194-201.\nRobbins, M.D. 8. Milliken, G. " Technology Transfer and the\nProcess of Technological Innovation: Hew Concepts, New\nModels ", R&D Management, vol.6, Special Issue on Techno-\n-logy Transfer,pp165-178.\nRobock, S.H. &. Simmonds, K. International Business and Multi-\nnational Enterprises, Homewood, III :Richard D. Irwin Inc.\n3/e, 1983, p.468.\nRosenberg, N. & C. Frischtak (1985), "International Technology\nTransfer", N. Y. : Praeger\nRoger. LN. "Key Concept and Models Including Technological\nChange for Economic Growth and Development", Michigan State\nU. Press, 1972, p.86.\nRobinson, R.D. "The International Transfer of Technology Theory\nIssues & Practice", Ballinger Publishing Co.,1988\nSchrader, S. "Informal Technology Transfer Between Firms:\nCoo per a t ion T h r 0 ugh In format ion T r a din g", Research Policy,\n28(1991), pp.153-170.\nSchroeder, D.M. & Hopley, R. "Product Development Strategies\nfor High-Tech Industries", The Jrnl of Business Strategy,\nMay/Jun 1988, pp.38-43.\n"Sharif, M.H. "Basis for Techno-Economic Policy Analysis" ,\nScience and Public Policy, 15-4, Aug.1988, pp.217-229.\nSmilor, R.W. & Gibson, D.V. "Accelerating Technology Transfer\nin R&D Consortia", Research Technologt Mgmt, Jan-Feb 1991,\npp.44-49.\nSmilor, R.W. & Gibson, D.V. "Technology Transfer in Multi-\nOrganizational Environments: The Case of R&D Consortia".\nIEEE Transactions on Engineering Mgmt., 38(1), Feb 1991,\npp.3-13.\nSolo, R.A. & Roger, E.M. "Inducing Technological Change for\nEconomic Growth and development, Michigan State U. Press,\n1972.\nSolo, R. “The Capacity to Assimilation an Advanced Technology\n", American Economic Review, 1966. pp91-97.\nSouder. W.E. "Managing Ne .. Product Innovations". Lexington\nBooks. 1987. pp.217-228.\nSouder, W.E. & Nassar. S. "Choosing an R&D Consortium". Re-\nsearch Technologt Mgmt. Mar-Apr 1998, pp.35-41.\nSouder, W.E. & Nassar, S. "Managing R&D Consortia for Success\nIf, Research Technologt Mgmt. Sep-Oct 1998, pp.44-58.\nSpencer, W.J. "Research to Product: A Major U.S. Challenge",\nCal. Mgmt Review. Winter 199B, pp.45-53.\nSteele, L.W. "Technology Maturation and Technology Substitu-\ntion", Feature, pp.11-24.\nStraub, D.W. "Validating Instruments in MIS Quarterly, June\n1989, pp.147-169.\nThe Technology Atlas Team, "Measurement of Level and Gap of\nTechnological Development", Technological Forcasting and\nSocial Change, 32, 1987, pp.49-68.\nTang, R.Y. & Tse, E. "Accounting Technology Transfer to Less\nDevelpoed Countries and the Singapore Experience", Columbia\nJrnl of World Business, 21(2), Summer 1986, pp.85-95.\nToyohiro Kono, N Factors Affecting the Creativity of Organi-\n-zations-An Approach from the Analysis of New Product Deve-\n-lopment ", Innovation and Management: International Compari-\n-sons, Editors: Kuniyoshi Urabe, John Child, Tadao Kagono,\nWalter de Gruyter & Co., 1988, pp.185-143.\nTsurumi, Y. “ Two Models of Corporation and International\nTransfer of Technology", Columbia Jrnl of World Business,\nSummer 1979, pp.43-58.\nTung, R. Business Negotiation with the Japanese, Lexington,\nMA. :Lexington Books, 1984.\nTung, R. "How to Negotiate with the Japanese."California\nManagement Review, 16, 4. Summer 1984, 62-77.\nVan der Meer. J.B.H. & Calori, R. “Strategic Management in\nTechnology-Intensive Industries", International Journal of\nTechnology Management, 4-2, 1989,\npp.127-139.\nVan Wyk, R.J. " Management of Technology: Hew Frameworks."\nTechnovation, 7(4), October 1988, pp.341-351.\nVan Wyk, R.J. "Technology Analysis and R&D Management" R&D\nMgmt, 28(3),1998, pp.257-261.\nVoss, C.A. "Success and Fai lure in Advanced Manufacturing\nTechnology", International Jrnl of Technology Mgmt. 3(3),\n1988, pp.285-297.\nWhite. R.M. "How Conytol Data Defines and Buys Technologies"\n, Electronic Business, 15(6), Mar.28, 1989, pp.111-114.\nWind, Y. & Mahajan, V. "New Product Development Process: A\nPerspective for Reexamination", Jrnl of Product Innovation\nMgmt, 5(4),1988, pp.384-\nWolff, M.F. "Technology Transfer: A GM Manager`s Strategy",\nResearch-Technology Mgmt., 32(5), Sep/Oct 1989, pp.9-1B.\nWortzel, R. "New Life Style Determinants of Women`s Food Sho-\n-pping Behavior", Journal of Marketing, 43, Summer 1979,\npp.28-29.\nWyckoff, A.W. & Tornatzky, L.G. "State-Level Efforts to Tra-\n-nsfer Manufacturing Technology: A Survey of Programs and\nPractices", Management Science, 34(4), Apr.1988, pp.469-481 描述 博士
國立政治大學
企業管理學系資料來源 http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#G91NCCV9982012 資料類型 thesis dc.contributor.advisor 劉水深<br>賴士葆 zh_TW dc.contributor.author (作者) 林明杰 zh_TW dc.creator (作者) 林明杰 zh_TW dc.date (日期) 1992 en_US dc.date.accessioned 10-五月-2016 18:51:59 (UTC+8) - dc.date.available 10-五月-2016 18:51:59 (UTC+8) - dc.date.issued (上傳時間) 10-五月-2016 18:51:59 (UTC+8) - dc.identifier (其他 識別碼) G91NCCV9982012 en_US dc.identifier.uri (URI) https://ah.lib.nccu.edu.tw/item?item_id=108445 - dc.description (描述) 博士 zh_TW dc.description (描述) 國立政治大學 zh_TW dc.description (描述) 企業管理學系 zh_TW dc.description.abstract (摘要) 在目前我國產業普遍面臨勞工短缺、匯率升值等不利的投資環境下，企業欲以產業昇級擺脫經營困境的最佳的方式，即是運由技術引進、整合、再發展為自有技術、以提昇本身基礎研究能力等過程，逐漸提昇技術水準，進而達成以技術進步強化競爭能力提昇經營績效以擺脫目前的困境。\n本研究初期經由相關文獻探討、及對企業的深度訪談發現，技術接受者本身技術能力為影響我國企業技術引進績效最重要的關鍵因素，因此整合過去學者的研究，建立技術能力與技術引進績效相關之研究架構，選擇自民國七十五年至七十九年底，在經濟部投資審議委員會登錄之合作案件，並以該期間中佔我國技術引進項目31.6%的電子電機業為母體，實證企業技術能力與技術引進績效間之關\n係，並分別探討引進技術特性、技術引進管理模式等中介變數對技術能力與引進績效間之影響。\n本研究對企業技術能力的衡量，除了參照Sharif、及賴士葆的分類外、並舉行國內實務專家座談等綜合後，將技術能力區分為1 .經驗能力2. 經費能力3 .設備能力 4 .產出能力5 .資訊能力6. 管理談判能力;等六個衡量構面。 問時以分析層級法(A H P )獲得各衡量構面應有的權重，以此計算各別企業在技術引進前之技術能力。\n本研究所使用的分析方法包括: 次數分配、單因子變異數分析、因素分析、集群分析、兩因子變異數分析、區別分析及交叉分析等。\n本研究發現技術引進者之技術能力與引進:績效間之關係，同時發現當技術接受者技術能力不足時，應、如何依本身狀況，挑選合適的技術引進，或在引進過程中調整管理模式，以提昇技術引進績效。 zh_TW dc.description.tableofcontents 考試委員簽名頁\n論文提要----------壹\n序言----------參\n目錄----------陸\n圖表目次----------玖\n附表目次----------拾參\n第一章:導論----------1\n第一節:研究動機----------1\n第二節:研究目的----------5\n第三節:研究流程----------6\n第四節:研究限制----------8\n本章註釋----------10\n第二章文獻探討----------14\n第一節:技術能力----------14\n第二節:技術引進績效----------22\n第三節:影響技術引進績效的因素----------25\n第四節:文獻探討摘要與研究範圍----------40\n第五節:個案研究----------41\n本章註釋----------42\n第三章研究設計----------42\n第一節:研究架構----------42\n第四節:研究變數定義----------45\n第三節:研究假設----------48\n第四節:研究對象----------51\n第五節:變數衡量與問卷設計----------53\n第六節:資料分析方法----------56\n第七節:問卷回收----------59\n第八節:信度與效度----------63\n第四章技術能力衡量及技術能力與技術引進績效之關係----------67\n第一節:技術能力衡量指標----------67\n第二節:技術能力----------76\n第三節:技術引進績效----------83\n第四節:技術能力與技術引進績效之關係----------90\n第五章技術特性、技術引進管理對技術能力與績效關係之影響----------97\n第一節:技術特性對能力與績效關係之影響----------97\n第二節:技術引進管理對能力與績效關係之影響----------115\n第六章結論與建議----------137\n第一節:研究結論----------137\n第二節:本研究貢獻----------144\n第三節:後續研究建議----------148\n參考書目----------149\n附錄一:個案研究----------163\n附錄二:研究問卷----------173\n附錄三:專家座談會名單----------179\n附錄四:分析層級程序法問卷及應用說明----------180\n附錄五:協助本研究進行之信函樣本----------188\n附表:本研究附表----------192\n作者簡歷----------204 zh_TW dc.source.uri (資料來源) http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#G91NCCV9982012 en_US dc.title (題名) 技術能力與技術引進績效相關之研究 zh_TW dc.type (資料類型) thesis en_US dc.relation.reference (參考文獻) 1中文部份\n－－－，"技術合作條例"，經濟部投資處印行，民國75年4月。\n───，"中華民國科學技術年鑑(民國七十八年)，行政院國家科學\n委員會編印，民國79年9月出版。\n───，經濟部投資審議委員會，"中華民國設術合作統計月報”，民\n國七十九年八月出版。\n－──"，經濟部產業技術發展概要79年度"，民國88年2月，\n毛倩文我國廠商國際技術進成敗關鍵因素之研究..國立政治大學\n國際貿易研究所未出版碩士論文，民國88年1月。\n王志剛，"我國工業科技移轉之現況"，自由化下的科技發展與科技政\n策學術研討會論文集，民國76年9月26日。\n王連常福"技術引進與我國工業結構之改變"，經濟研究，22，民國\n68年7月。\n司徒達賢、李仁芳、吳忠華等合著，企業概論，教育部空中教學委員\n會，民國74年8月初版。\n李慶成，"多國籍企業與技術移轉之關係"，政治大學企業管理研究所\n未出版碩士論文，民國71年6月。\n杜震華，"研究發展對生產與貿易之效果"，中華民國科技管理學會，中\n華民國1991科技管理研討會為文集，民國80年10月。\n林由，"我國產業發展與研發體系之變遷"經濟部科技顧問室－產業\n科技研究發展管理論文集，民國79年6月。\n林明杰，"研究發展與製造之介面研究，國立政治大學企業管理研究\n所，未出版碩士論文，民國77年6月。\n林鴻鈞，"台灣機械業技術引進的成本與效益"，台銀季刊，33(3)，民\n國71年9月。\n周榮堅，"技術移轉決策因素研究"，國立政治大學企業管理研究所未\n出版碩士論文，民國74年6月。\n吳家馨，"生產力指揮研究報告"，中國生產力中心，民國75年6月。\n青柳全原著，黃南斗、葉錦堂譯，"新產品開發實務指南?，台華工商\n圖書出版公司，民76年8月初版。\n陳定園、徐金水，”中外技術合作之有效途徑(條件與程序)”，台北:\n工業技術研究院金屬研究院，民國67年6月。\n許士軍，管理學，東華書書，民國71年3月二版。\n湯明哲，"策略規劃與技術創新的介面”，經濟部科技顧問室:產業科\n技研究發展管理論文集，民圍79年6月14日。\n黃家齊，"技術引進成效影響因素之研究”，私立中原大學企業管理研\n究所未出版碩士論文，民國79年6月。\n曾建動，”技術移轉對產品開發活動之影響"，國立政治大學企業管理\n研究所未出版碩士論文，民國73年6月。\n詹文瑛，日本政府出資之研究開發與成果移轉探討，工業投術研究院\n工業經濟研究中心，民國79年3月出版。\n蔡敦浩，"科技變遷趨勢與企業科技創新策酪-新興工業化國家的觀點\n“，經濟部科技顧問室:產業科技研究發展管理論文集，民國79年6月\n蔡敦浩，”日本企業科技管理特性初探”，中華民國科技管理學會，中華\n民國1991科技管理研討會論文集。民間88年10月。\n齊世基，刊機械工業的技術移轉\n鄭優， ”我國工業科技移轉之研究:影響技術引進成效因素之探討"，\n國立政治大學企業管理研究所未出版碩士論文，民國78年6月。\n賴士葆，"企業技術特性與新產品發展績效相關之研究”，管理評論：\n國立政治大學企管研究所出版，民國76年7月。\n賴士葆、林明杰， ”研究發展與製造兩部門互動之研究"，管理評論，\n國立政治大學企管研究所:光華管理策進基金會圖書部發行，民國\n78年7月。\n賴士葆，"研究發展/行銷/製造三部門互動與新產品發展績效相關之\n研究"，華泰書局，民國79年6月。\n賴士葆，”企業技術引進方式與其績效間相關之研究”，國立政治大學\n企管研究所，民國79年7月。\n賴榮仁，"美、日在台企業管理技術移轉之研究”，國立政治大學企業\n管理研究所未出版博士論文，民國75年1月。\n薛琦& Majumder, B.”內生技術變動與經濟發展”，中國經濟學會論文\n集，民國67年12月。\n薛琦，"我國電子電器製造業技術合作實施成果調查報告"，”我國機械\n儀器製造業技術合作實施成果調查報告"，"我國化學業技術合作實\n路成果調查報告”，"我國基本金屬及金屬製品製造業技術合作實施\n成果調查報告，經濟部投資審議委員會，民國69年-民國72年。\n薛琦，(1987)，"我國產業的技術移轉與技術發展"，中美技術合作作研\n究會、工商時報聯合舉辦之，自由化下的科技發展與科技政策學術\n研討會，民國76年9月26日。\n薛琦，"技術引進的途徑與效益”，中國論壇，253期，民76年。\n謝安田，企業研究方法，作者自印，民國72年。\n蕭峰雄，”當前推動技術移轉之課題”中美技術季刊，29(2)，民國73\n年6月。\n蕭峰雄、周皎瑜，"我國財團法人研究機構技術移轉之研究-積體電路\n與機器人之個案研究”，作者未發表論文，民74年。\n嚴永晃，"技術合作三十年的省思"，經濟雜誌，34，民國76年2月。\n二、英文部份\nAbernathy, W. J. & Utterback, J.M. " Dynamic Model of Process\nand Product Innovation ", Omega, 3(6),1975, pp.639-657.\nAuster, E.R. "International Corporate Linkages: Dynamic Forms\nIn Changing Environments", Columbia Jrnl of World Business,\n22(2), Summer 1987, pp.3-6.\nArnoni. Kossik. Peavy(1987), "Transfer Technology Successfully\n" Hydrocarbon Processing, 66(18). Oct.1987, pp.55-66.\nBae. Zongtae & Jinjoo Lee , "Technology Development Patterns\nof Small and Medium Sized Companies in the Korean Machinery\nIndustry " Technovation, 4, 1986, pp.279-296.\nBaker, H.R.; Green, S.G.; & Bean, A.S. "The need for Strategic\nBalance in R&D Project Portfolios", Research Mgmt, Mar-Apr.,\n1986. pp.38-43.\nBaranson, J. "Transfer of Technical Knowledge by International\nCorporations to Developing Economics", AER 1966, P.259.\nBarbiroli, G.,"A New Method to evaluate the Special and Global\nAdvantage of a Technology", Technovation, 18(2). i4ar.1998,\npp.73-93.\nBaron, S, "Overcoming Barriers to Technology Transfer", Rese-\n-arch Technology mgmt, Jan-Feb 1998, pp.38-43.\nBarton, D.L., "Implementation as Mutual Adaptation of Techno-\nlogy and Organization", Research Policy, (17),1988, pp.251-267.\nBrown, M.A. & Berry, L.G. "Guidelines for Successfully Tra-\nnsferring Government-Sponsored Innovations", Research Policy\n20(1991), pp.121-143.\nBylinsky, G. "Turning R&D into Real Products", Fortune, 122\n(1), Ju1.2 1990, pp.72-77.\nChakrabarti, A.K. & Souder, W.E. "Technology Innovation and\nPerformance in Corporate Mergers: A Managerial Evaluation"\n,Technovation, 6, 1987, pp.103-114.\nChanaron , J. J. & Perrin, J. "The Transfer of Research, Deve-\n-lopment and Design to Developing Countries", Futures, Oct.\n1987, pp.503-512.\nCooper, R.G. "The Strategy Performance Link in Product Inno-\nvation ", R&D Management, 14-4. pp. 247-259.\nCutler, W. G. "Acquiring Technology From Outside", Research-Technology\nmgrnt, May-Jun 1991, pp.11-18.\n( Daft, R.L. & Lengel, R.H. "Organizational Information Requi-\nrements, Media Richness and Structural Design", Management\nScience, 32-5, May 1985, pp.554-571.\nDess, G.G. & Robinson, R.B. "Measuring Organizational Perfo-\n-rmance In the Absence of Objective Measures: The Case of\nPrivetely-Held Firm and Conglomerate Business Unit", Stra-\ntegic Mgmt Jrnl. ,5, 1984.\nDierdonck, R. Van "The Manufacturing/Design Interface", R&D\nManagement, 20 (3), 1990, pp. 203-209.\nDixon, J.R. & Duffey M.R. “The Neglect of Engineering Design\n“, Cal. Mgmt Review, Winter 1998, pp.9-23.\nDjeflat, A. "The Management of Technology Transfer: Views and\nExperiences of Developing Countries", Int. Jrnl. Technology\nManagement. 3-1/2, 1988, pp.149-165.\nDoll, W. J. & Torkzadeh, G. "The Measurement of End-User Compu-\nting Satisification", MIS Quarterly, 12(2), June 1988. pp.\n258-273.\nDamar, E.D. "On the Measurement of Technological Change", Eco-\nnomics Jrnl, 1961, pp.789-714.\nFagerberg, J. "A Technology Gap Approach to Why Growth Rates\nDiffer", Research Policy 16(1987), pp.87-99\nFrair, J. & Horwitch, M. "The Emergence of Technology Strategy\nIf, Technology in the Modern Corporation - A Strategic Pers-\npective, ed by Mel Horwitch, N Y: Pergamon Press Inc., 1986.\nGalbraith, C.S. "Transferring Core Manufacturing Technologies\nin High-Technology Firms", Cal. Mgmt Review, Summer 1990,\npp.56-78.\nGee, S. "The Role of Technology Transfer in Innovation", Re-\nsearch mgmt, Nov. 1974, PP.\nGerstenfield, A. "Effective management of Research and Deve-\n-lopment, Reading Mass. Addison-Wesley Pub. Co., 1978, pp41.\nGodkin, L. "Problems and Practicalities of Technology Transfer\n: A Survey of the Literature", International Jornal of Tech-\nnology Management, 3(5), 1988. pp.587-683.\nGupta, A.K. et al. "Managing the R&D-Marketing Interface"\nResearch Mgmt, 38(2), Mar/Apr 1987, pp.38-43.\nGupta, A.K. & Wilemon D.L. "Accelerating the Development of\nTechnology-Based Hew Products", Cal. Mgmt Review, Winter\n1998, pp.24-44.\nHabibie, B.J. "Sophisticated Technologies: Taking Root in De-\nveloping Countries~, International Jrnl of Technology Mgmt\n.,5(5),1990, pp.489-497.\nHakam, A.N. & Chang. Z. Y. "Patterns of Technology Transfer in\nSingapore:The Case of the Electronics and Computer Industry\n", Int. J. Technology Management, 3-1/2,1988, pp.181-188.\nHarvey, E. II Technology and The Structure of Organizations",\nAmerican Socialogical Review, 33, 1968, pp.247-259.\nHayes R.H. and Wheelwright S.C., "Restoring our Competitive\nEdge", 台北,華泰書局翻印,民國75年。\nHickson, D.J.; Pugh, D.S.; Pheysey, D.C. "Operations Techno-\nlogy and Organization Structure: An Empirical Reappraisal\n", Administrative Science Quarterly, Sep.1969, p.378.\nHendryx, S.R. "Implementation of a Technology Transfer Joint\nVenture in The People`s Republic of China: A Management\nPerspective”, Columbia Jrnl of World Business, 21(1),Spring\n1986, pp.57-66.\nJohnson, H.G. "Technology and Economic Independence", N Y:St.\nMartin`s Press for Trade Policy Research Center of London\n, 1976.\nKast, F. E. & Rosenzweig, J.E. "Organization & management: A\nsystem and Con tangency Approach",台北:淡江書局,民國74年\n8月一版, pp. 208-210.\nKeller, R.T. & Chinta, R.R. "International technology transfer\n: Strategies for Success", Academy of management Executive,\n4-2, May.199B, pp.33-43.\nKerlinger, F.N. "Foundations of Behavior Research", 3rd./ed.,\nNew York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 1986, p.443.\nKojima, Kiyoshi, "Transfer of Technology to Developing Coun-\n-tries-Japanese Type Versus American Type", Hitotsbubashi\nJrnl of Economics, 17(2), Feb.1977, pp.1-14.\nKokubo, A. "Japan`s R&D Managers Confront the Challenge of\nHigh Tech", R&D Magazine, 32(6), Jun. 199B, pp.83-86.\nKrishna, E.M. & Rao, C.P. "Is US High Technology High Enough\n", Columbia Jrnl of World Business, 21(2), Summer 1986, pp.\n47-54.\nKuzuets, S. "Modern Economic Growth, Rate Structure and Spread\n" , New Haven, Yale Univ. Press, 1965.\nLandau, R. "Harnessing Innovation for Growth", Chemical Engi-\n-neerlng Progress, 84(7), Jul. 1988, pp.31-42.\nLasserre, P. "Selecting a Foreign Partner for Technology Tra-\n-nsfer", Long Range Planning, 17(6), 1984, pp.43-49.\nLefebvre, L.A.; Harvey, J. and Lefebvre, E. " Technological\nExperience and the Technology Adoption In Small Manufactu-\n-ring Firms", R&D Mgmt, 21(3),1991, pp.241-249.\nLeroy, G.P. "Transfer of Developing Economics `Within the Mu-\n-ltinational Enterprise", 1978\nLin, Yeo, " Technology Change: A Microeconomic Study of the\nCRT-Relate consumer electronics Industry in Taiwan, U. of\nSan Diego, (1987),pp9B7-921.\nMadeuf, B. "International Technology Transfers and Internati-\nonal Technology Payments: Definitions, Measurement and\nFirms t Behaviour", Research Po 1 icy, 13 (1984), pp.125-1413.\nMadu C.N. "Transferring Technology to Developing Countries-Critical\nFactors for Sucess", Long Range Planning, 22(4),\n1989, pp.115-124.\nMadu, C.N. "Prescriptive Framework for the Transfer of Appro-\npriate Technology", Futures, Hov. 19913, pp.932-9513.\nMansour, M.B.; Hawkin, R.G.; & Prasad, A.J. "Definitional Issues\nin Technology Transfer: Channels, Mechanisms and Resources",\nTechnology Transfer and Development, 1981, p.l-l13.\nMaidique, M.A. & Patch, P. "Cooperate Strategy and Technological\nPolicy", in Tushman & Moore ed., Reading in the Management of\nInnovation, (Pitman: 1982).\nMajor, J.D. "Some Practical Intellectual Property Aspects of\nTechnology Transfer H\n, International Jrnl of Technology Mgmt\n,3(1/2),1988, pp.43-49.\nMansfield, E. "International Technology Transfer Resource\nRequirements and Policies", American Economic Association.\n68(2), May. 1975, pp.372-376.\nMartin, M.J.C. "Managing Technological Innovation and Enter-\n-preneuership", Reston, Virginia, Reston Publishing Co., Inc\n. 1984 , pp235.\nMeyer, A.D. "Tech Talk: How Managers Are Stimulating Global\nR&D Communication", Sloan Mgmt Review, Spring 1991, pp.49-\n58.\nMeyer, M.H. & Robert, E.B. "Focusing Product Technology for\nCorporate Growth", Sloan Mgmt Review, Summer 1988, pp.7-16.\nMitchell, W. "Using Academic Technology: Transfer Methods &\nLicensing Incidence in the Commercialization of American\nDiagnostic Imaging Equipment Research, 1954-1988 " , Research\nPolicy, 20(1991), pp.203-216 .\nMorbey, G. K. "R&D Expenditures and Profit Growth", Research\nTechnology Management, 32(3), May/Jun 1989, PP.20-23.\nMoriarty, R.T. & Kosnik, T.J. "High-Tech Marketing: Concepts,\nContinuity, and Change", Sloan Mgmt Review, Summer 1989, p.7\nOliva, T.A. "Information and Profitability Estimates: Modell\n-ing the Firm`s Decision to Adopt a New Technology", Mgmt\nScience, 37(5), May 1991, pp.687-623.\nPerrino, A.C. Tipping, J.W. "Global Management of Technology",\nResearch technology management, 32(3), May/Jun. 1989, pp.12-19 .\nPorter, M.E. "Competitive Advantage", New York: Free Press,\n1985, p.37.\nPrasad, S.B. "Technology Transfer: The Approach of a Dutch\nMultinational", Technovation, 4(1986), pp.3-15.\nQuinn, J.B. "Technology Transfer by Multinational Companies",\nHBR, Nov-Dec 1969.\nOunjian, M.L. & Carne, E.B. (1987) , .. A Study of the Factors\nWhich Affect Technology Transfer in a Multilocation Multi-Business\nUnit Corporation", IEEE Transactions on Engineering\nManagement, Vol.EM-34,H0.3, August, 1987, pp.194-201.\nRobbins, M.D. 8. Milliken, G. " Technology Transfer and the\nProcess of Technological Innovation: Hew Concepts, New\nModels ", R&D Management, vol.6, Special Issue on Techno-\n-logy Transfer,pp165-178.\nRobock, S.H. &. Simmonds, K. International Business and Multi-\nnational Enterprises, Homewood, III :Richard D. Irwin Inc.\n3/e, 1983, p.468.\nRosenberg, N. & C. Frischtak (1985), "International Technology\nTransfer", N. Y. : Praeger\nRoger. LN. "Key Concept and Models Including Technological\nChange for Economic Growth and Development", Michigan State\nU. Press, 1972, p.86.\nRobinson, R.D. "The International Transfer of Technology Theory\nIssues & Practice", Ballinger Publishing Co.,1988\nSchrader, S. "Informal Technology Transfer Between Firms:\nCoo per a t ion T h r 0 ugh In format ion T r a din g", Research Policy,\n28(1991), pp.153-170.\nSchroeder, D.M. & Hopley, R. "Product Development Strategies\nfor High-Tech Industries", The Jrnl of Business Strategy,\nMay/Jun 1988, pp.38-43.\n"Sharif, M.H. "Basis for Techno-Economic Policy Analysis" ,\nScience and Public Policy, 15-4, Aug.1988, pp.217-229.\nSmilor, R.W. & Gibson, D.V. "Accelerating Technology Transfer\nin R&D Consortia", Research Technologt Mgmt, Jan-Feb 1991,\npp.44-49.\nSmilor, R.W. & Gibson, D.V. "Technology Transfer in Multi-\nOrganizational Environments: The Case of R&D Consortia".\nIEEE Transactions on Engineering Mgmt., 38(1), Feb 1991,\npp.3-13.\nSolo, R.A. & Roger, E.M. "Inducing Technological Change for\nEconomic Growth and development, Michigan State U. Press,\n1972.\nSolo, R. “The Capacity to Assimilation an Advanced Technology\n", American Economic Review, 1966. pp91-97.\nSouder. W.E. "Managing Ne .. Product Innovations". Lexington\nBooks. 1987. pp.217-228.\nSouder, W.E. & Nassar. S. "Choosing an R&D Consortium". Re-\nsearch Technologt Mgmt. Mar-Apr 1998, pp.35-41.\nSouder, W.E. & Nassar, S. "Managing R&D Consortia for Success\nIf, Research Technologt Mgmt. Sep-Oct 1998, pp.44-58.\nSpencer, W.J. "Research to Product: A Major U.S. Challenge",\nCal. Mgmt Review. Winter 199B, pp.45-53.\nSteele, L.W. "Technology Maturation and Technology Substitu-\ntion", Feature, pp.11-24.\nStraub, D.W. "Validating Instruments in MIS Quarterly, June\n1989, pp.147-169.\nThe Technology Atlas Team, "Measurement of Level and Gap of\nTechnological Development", Technological Forcasting and\nSocial Change, 32, 1987, pp.49-68.\nTang, R.Y. & Tse, E. "Accounting Technology Transfer to Less\nDevelpoed Countries and the Singapore Experience", Columbia\nJrnl of World Business, 21(2), Summer 1986, pp.85-95.\nToyohiro Kono, N Factors Affecting the Creativity of Organi-\n-zations-An Approach from the Analysis of New Product Deve-\n-lopment ", Innovation and Management: International Compari-\n-sons, Editors: Kuniyoshi Urabe, John Child, Tadao Kagono,\nWalter de Gruyter & Co., 1988, pp.185-143.\nTsurumi, Y. “ Two Models of Corporation and International\nTransfer of Technology", Columbia Jrnl of World Business,\nSummer 1979, pp.43-58.\nTung, R. Business Negotiation with the Japanese, Lexington,\nMA. :Lexington Books, 1984.\nTung, R. "How to Negotiate with the Japanese."California\nManagement Review, 16, 4. Summer 1984, 62-77.\nVan der Meer. J.B.H. & Calori, R. “Strategic Management in\nTechnology-Intensive Industries", International Journal of\nTechnology Management, 4-2, 1989,\npp.127-139.\nVan Wyk, R.J. " Management of Technology: Hew Frameworks."\nTechnovation, 7(4), October 1988, pp.341-351.\nVan Wyk, R.J. "Technology Analysis and R&D Management" R&D\nMgmt, 28(3),1998, pp.257-261.\nVoss, C.A. "Success and Fai lure in Advanced Manufacturing\nTechnology", International Jrnl of Technology Mgmt. 3(3),\n1988, pp.285-297.\nWhite. R.M. "How Conytol Data Defines and Buys Technologies"\n, Electronic Business, 15(6), Mar.28, 1989, pp.111-114.\nWind, Y. & Mahajan, V. "New Product Development Process: A\nPerspective for Reexamination", Jrnl of Product Innovation\nMgmt, 5(4),1988, pp.384-\nWolff, M.F. "Technology Transfer: A GM Manager`s Strategy",\nResearch-Technology Mgmt., 32(5), Sep/Oct 1989, pp.9-1B.\nWortzel, R. "New Life Style Determinants of Women`s Food Sho-\n-pping Behavior", Journal of Marketing, 43, Summer 1979,\npp.28-29.\nWyckoff, A.W. & Tornatzky, L.G. "State-Level Efforts to Tra-\n-nsfer Manufacturing Technology: A Survey of Programs and\nPractices", Management Science, 34(4), Apr.1988, pp.469-481 zh_TW
