學術產出-期刊論文

文章檢視/開啟

書目匯出

Google ScholarTM

政大圖書館

引文資訊

TAIR相關學術產出

題名 春秋時期族群概念新探
其他題名 A New Study on the Chinese Ethnic Thought during the Spring and Autumn Period
作者 張其賢
Chishen Chang
貢獻者 政治系
關鍵詞 族群 ; 春秋時期 ; 諸夏 ; 蠻夷戎狄 ; 內外
Ethnicity ; Spring-Autumn Period ; Zhuxia ; Man ; Yi ; Rong ; Di ; Outsider ; Insider
日期 2009.03
上傳時間 29-七月-2014 17:09:44 (UTC+8)
摘要 本文企圖質疑學界長久以來的兩種看法。第一種看法,是認爲春秋時期已經有某種族群意識,即「諸夏」意識。第二種看法,是認爲「諸夏」和「蠻」、「夷」、「戎」、「狄」的主要區別是一種文野之別,即一種文明先進者和野蠻落後者的區別。針對第一種看法,筆者論證指出,「諸夏」並不是一個族群概念,而是一種政治集團概念。這個政治集團的成員雖然有某種我群概念,但這種我群概念還沒有發展成族群意識。針對第二種看法,筆者論證指出,春秋時期「蠻」、「夷」、「戎」、「狄」的稱呼,其主要意涵其實是「外人」而不是「文化落後之人」。因此,在春秋時期「諸夏」之人的認知中,他們自己和「蠻」、「夷」、「戎」、「狄」的最主要區別,並不是文化先進落後之別,而是一種內外之別;文化先進落後之別雖然存在,卻不像內外之別那樣經常被提及。
This article intends to challenge two prevalent views regarding the Chinese ethnic concepts during the Spring-Autumn period. According to the first view, certain ethnic consciousness (the "Zhuxia consciousness") has appeared in the Spring-Autumn period. According to the second view, the main distinction between Zhuxia and Man, Yi, Rong, Di is one between the civilized and the barbarian. Against the first view, the author argues that the term Zhuxia had little ethnic connotation but instead referred to certain political group. Although members of this political group did have certain concept of belonging to the same group, such concept fell short of developing into an ethnic consciousness. Against the second view, the author argues that the main connotation of the terms Man, Yi, Rong, Di during the Spring-Autumn period was "outsiders" rather than "barbarians" or "secondary peoples". To the people of Zhuxia, the major distinction between Zhuxia and Man, Yi, Rong, Di was not so much that between the civilized and the barbarian as that between "outsiders" and "insiders".
關聯 政治科學論叢, 39, 85-158
資料類型 article
dc.contributor 政治系en_US
dc.creator (作者) 張其賢zh_TW
dc.creator (作者) Chishen Changen_US
dc.date (日期) 2009.03en_US
dc.date.accessioned 29-七月-2014 17:09:44 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.available 29-七月-2014 17:09:44 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.issued (上傳時間) 29-七月-2014 17:09:44 (UTC+8)-
dc.identifier.uri (URI) http://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/67951-
dc.description.abstract (摘要) 本文企圖質疑學界長久以來的兩種看法。第一種看法,是認爲春秋時期已經有某種族群意識,即「諸夏」意識。第二種看法,是認爲「諸夏」和「蠻」、「夷」、「戎」、「狄」的主要區別是一種文野之別,即一種文明先進者和野蠻落後者的區別。針對第一種看法,筆者論證指出,「諸夏」並不是一個族群概念,而是一種政治集團概念。這個政治集團的成員雖然有某種我群概念,但這種我群概念還沒有發展成族群意識。針對第二種看法,筆者論證指出,春秋時期「蠻」、「夷」、「戎」、「狄」的稱呼,其主要意涵其實是「外人」而不是「文化落後之人」。因此,在春秋時期「諸夏」之人的認知中,他們自己和「蠻」、「夷」、「戎」、「狄」的最主要區別,並不是文化先進落後之別,而是一種內外之別;文化先進落後之別雖然存在,卻不像內外之別那樣經常被提及。en_US
dc.description.abstract (摘要) This article intends to challenge two prevalent views regarding the Chinese ethnic concepts during the Spring-Autumn period. According to the first view, certain ethnic consciousness (the "Zhuxia consciousness") has appeared in the Spring-Autumn period. According to the second view, the main distinction between Zhuxia and Man, Yi, Rong, Di is one between the civilized and the barbarian. Against the first view, the author argues that the term Zhuxia had little ethnic connotation but instead referred to certain political group. Although members of this political group did have certain concept of belonging to the same group, such concept fell short of developing into an ethnic consciousness. Against the second view, the author argues that the main connotation of the terms Man, Yi, Rong, Di during the Spring-Autumn period was "outsiders" rather than "barbarians" or "secondary peoples". To the people of Zhuxia, the major distinction between Zhuxia and Man, Yi, Rong, Di was not so much that between the civilized and the barbarian as that between "outsiders" and "insiders".en_US
dc.format.extent 2219490 bytes-
dc.format.mimetype application/pdf-
dc.language.iso en_US-
dc.relation (關聯) 政治科學論叢, 39, 85-158en_US
dc.subject (關鍵詞) 族群 ; 春秋時期 ; 諸夏 ; 蠻夷戎狄 ; 內外en_US
dc.subject (關鍵詞) Ethnicity ; Spring-Autumn Period ; Zhuxia ; Man ; Yi ; Rong ; Di ; Outsider ; Insideren_US
dc.title (題名) 春秋時期族群概念新探zh_TW
dc.title.alternative (其他題名) A New Study on the Chinese Ethnic Thought during the Spring and Autumn Perioden_US
dc.type (資料類型) articleen