學術產出-期刊論文

文章檢視/開啟

書目匯出

Google ScholarTM

政大圖書館

引文資訊

TAIR相關學術產出

題名 刑法第二二二條第一項第一款「二人以上共同犯之」之適用思考
其他題名 A Study on Violent Sexual Offences Committed by More than Two Perpetrators
作者 李聖傑
Lee, Sheng-Chieh
貢獻者 法律系
關鍵詞 複行為人強制性交罪 ; 共同強制性交 ; 必要共同正犯 ; 性價值 ; 刑法解釋
Violent sexual offences ; Necessary joint principles ; Value of sex ; Interpretive methods of criminal law
日期 2010.06
上傳時間 30-九月-2014 17:50:19 (UTC+8)
摘要 刑法第二二二條第一項第一款「二人以上共同犯之」的行為樣態,不論是在實務應用或學說的釋義,都還存在著相當的爭議。相對於學說對於規範適用的不同闡釋主張,就相關實務判決的分析呈現上,最高法院顯然傾向以行為人是否有「二人以上共同參與」的文義認定,作為規範適用的主要判斷標準。從罪質加以觀察,刑法第二二二條第一項第一款之複行為人強制性交罪,為必要共同正犯之聚合犯。然而所謂必要共同正犯的罪質,不能只是來自於刑法的文義規定,更應該有其犯罪型態所必須具備的行為模式。本文因此在整理近來最高法院的相關判決後,先以經過簡化的案例事實,介紹我國實務對於刑法第二二二條「二人以上共同犯之」的應用立場。其次再利用刑法各種解釋方法,探求該規範合理的應用空間。本文並且考量性自主法益的特殊價值,論述刑法第二二二條第一項第一款之行為類型的罪質,希望能因此釐清我國刑法第二二二條第一項第一款在實務應用的疑義。
How does one interpret “more than two individual committing a crime” in section 1 of paragraph 1 of Article 222 of the Criminal Law has been hotly debated in theory and practice. The Supreme Court, in contrast to the theoretical interpretations, is obviously in favor of focusing on the literal meaning of the Article to see whether the crime is committed by more than two individuals. However, if we look into the nature of violent sexual offences, group offenders, a type of the necessary joint principles, can better meet the requirements of section 1 of paragraph 1 of Article 222.This essay will review recent decisions made by the Supreme Court, and, based on the interpretive methods of criminal law, analyze how the clause “more than two perpetrators committing a crime” of Article 222 is applied in practice. The value of self-determination involving sexual activities will also be discussed in this essay to clarify the meaning of section 1 of paragraph 1 of Article 222. In short, this essay aims to provide a new way examine the aforementioned debate.
關聯 法學評論 , 115 , 1-54
資料類型 article
dc.contributor 法律系en_US
dc.creator (作者) 李聖傑zh_TW
dc.creator (作者) Lee, Sheng-Chiehen_US
dc.date (日期) 2010.06en_US
dc.date.accessioned 30-九月-2014 17:50:19 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.available 30-九月-2014 17:50:19 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.issued (上傳時間) 30-九月-2014 17:50:19 (UTC+8)-
dc.identifier.uri (URI) http://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/70240-
dc.description.abstract (摘要) 刑法第二二二條第一項第一款「二人以上共同犯之」的行為樣態,不論是在實務應用或學說的釋義,都還存在著相當的爭議。相對於學說對於規範適用的不同闡釋主張,就相關實務判決的分析呈現上,最高法院顯然傾向以行為人是否有「二人以上共同參與」的文義認定,作為規範適用的主要判斷標準。從罪質加以觀察,刑法第二二二條第一項第一款之複行為人強制性交罪,為必要共同正犯之聚合犯。然而所謂必要共同正犯的罪質,不能只是來自於刑法的文義規定,更應該有其犯罪型態所必須具備的行為模式。本文因此在整理近來最高法院的相關判決後,先以經過簡化的案例事實,介紹我國實務對於刑法第二二二條「二人以上共同犯之」的應用立場。其次再利用刑法各種解釋方法,探求該規範合理的應用空間。本文並且考量性自主法益的特殊價值,論述刑法第二二二條第一項第一款之行為類型的罪質,希望能因此釐清我國刑法第二二二條第一項第一款在實務應用的疑義。en_US
dc.description.abstract (摘要) How does one interpret “more than two individual committing a crime” in section 1 of paragraph 1 of Article 222 of the Criminal Law has been hotly debated in theory and practice. The Supreme Court, in contrast to the theoretical interpretations, is obviously in favor of focusing on the literal meaning of the Article to see whether the crime is committed by more than two individuals. However, if we look into the nature of violent sexual offences, group offenders, a type of the necessary joint principles, can better meet the requirements of section 1 of paragraph 1 of Article 222.This essay will review recent decisions made by the Supreme Court, and, based on the interpretive methods of criminal law, analyze how the clause “more than two perpetrators committing a crime” of Article 222 is applied in practice. The value of self-determination involving sexual activities will also be discussed in this essay to clarify the meaning of section 1 of paragraph 1 of Article 222. In short, this essay aims to provide a new way examine the aforementioned debate.en_US
dc.format.extent 798417 bytes-
dc.format.mimetype application/pdf-
dc.language.iso en_US-
dc.relation (關聯) 法學評論 , 115 , 1-54en_US
dc.subject (關鍵詞) 複行為人強制性交罪 ; 共同強制性交 ; 必要共同正犯 ; 性價值 ; 刑法解釋en_US
dc.subject (關鍵詞) Violent sexual offences ; Necessary joint principles ; Value of sex ; Interpretive methods of criminal lawen_US
dc.title (題名) 刑法第二二二條第一項第一款「二人以上共同犯之」之適用思考zh_TW
dc.title.alternative (其他題名) A Study on Violent Sexual Offences Committed by More than Two Perpetratorsen_US
dc.type (資料類型) articleen