When Strategies and Politics Collide: Rethinking "Revisiting Taiwan`s Defense Strategy"

Abstract

In 2008, William S. Murray published an article ”Revisiting Taiwan`s Defense Strategy” calling for an army-centric ”porcupine strategy” The article gathered significant attention from the highest authorities in Taipei but was condemned roundly. This essay argues that, except for a few flaws, Murray`s article is generally correct, and that the criticisms do not withstand scrutiny. Based on Taiwan`s strategy up to 2008, these criticisms stem form a perception of low Taiwanese morale, but provide no solutions to the issues they raise. Taking into consideration the post-2008 developments, this essay argues that, by turning Taiwan`s China policy in a more widely supportable direction, the will to fight is strengthened. The essay then provides three simple but fundamental recommendations: have a more balanced force, structure, avoid the allure of retaliation, and talk straight.