Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://ah.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/87639


Title: 麥金泰爾論德性的社群
MacIntyre on Virtuous Community
Authors: 黃昭榮
Huang, Chao-Jung
Contributors: 江宜樺
黃昭榮
Huang, Chao-Jung
Keywords: 麥金泰爾
亞里斯多德
社群
德性
自由主義
社群主義
MacIntyre
Aristotle
community
virtue
liberalism
communitarainism
Date: 1995
Issue Date: 2016-04-28 15:22:14 (UTC+8)
Abstract: 本文的主旨在於探討當代美國哲學家麥金泰爾(1929-)的政治思想。麥金泰爾以亞里斯多德的理論來構築他心中理想的政治社群。並據此批駁自由主義所建構的政治社群。本研究擬藉此論爭以深入討論政治社群的本質。而整個研究是奠基在麥金泰爾後期(1981-)的著作。全文共分四章,分別略述如下。 第一章 緒論 旨在說明本研究的動機與目的,並概述麥金泰爾政治思想的
Reference: 一、MacIntyre的歷年著作
1953- , MacIntyrea~M~~1'F
Marxism.An Interpretatiol1,London:SCM Press. Revised as Marxism
and Christianity. London:Duckworth, 1968.
1958-9"Notes from the Moral Wilderness I" . New Reasoner
1959a"Notes from the Moral Wilderness n 1/ ? New Reasoner 8:89-98.
1959b"Hume on - Is ~ and - Ought ~ II ? Philosophical Review,68:451-68.
1960"Breaking the Chains ofReasolll/ , in Out of Apathy, introduced by E.
P. Thompson. London:Stevens and Sons,pp.195-240.
1964"Against Utilitarianism'l ,in Aims in Eduacation:The Philosophic Approach,
ed. T. H. B. Hollins. Manchester:Manchester Ulliversity Press.
1966 A Short History of Ethics. New York: Macmillan.
1967 Secularisation and Moral Change. Riddell Memoriallecture,Delivered
At University of Newcastle Upon Tyne.Oxford:Oxford Ulliversity Press.
1968 Marxism and Christianity.LondonL:Duckworth.
1969a "The Debate About God : Victorian Relevance and Contemporary
Inelevancel/ ,in Alasdair MacIntyre and Paul Ricoeuf,The Religious
Significance of Atheism. Columbia:Columbia Univergity Press.
1969b "Philosophy and Sanity:Nietzsche's Titanisml/ . Encounter 32:79-84.
1971 Against the Self-Images of the Age: Essays 011 Ideology alld Philosophy.
London: Do ckworth.
1971-2 "Praxis and Action 1/ ? Review of Metaphysics 25:737-44.
1972a "Predictability and Explanation in the Social Sciencesl/ . Philosophic
Exchange 1(3):5-13 .
1972b " Justice:a New Theory and Some Old Question '! . Boston University
Lmv Review 52:330-34.
1972-3 " Ideology,Social Science,and Revolution // . ConzparativePolitics 5 :
321-42.
1973-4 "Ancient Politics and Modern Issuesl/. Arion, NS 1:425-30.
1975 "How Virtues Become Vices Medicine and Societyl/. Ecollnter 45: 11
- 17.
1976a "On Democrantic Theory:Retrieval by C. B. Macphersonl/. Canadian
Journal of Philosophy 6:177-8l.
1976b "Power and Virtue in the American Republicl/. The Case For alld
Against P(J1.ver for the Federal Governnzent.Ripon:Ripon CoUege press,
pp.16-20.
1977a "Epistemological Crises,Drmatic Narrative,and the Philosophy of Science
/~ The Adollis! 60:453-72.
1977b "Utilitarianism and the Presupposition of Cost-Benefit Analysis'!.
1978a
Value in the Electric Power industry,NotreDame:University of Notre
Dame Press,pp.217-37.
"What Has Ethics to Learn from Medical Ethics?// Philosophy Exchange
2:37-47.
1978b "Objectivity in Morality and Objectivity in Sciencel/. lv/orals,Sciellce
Sociality, Hastings Center,Hastings-on-Hudsin 21-39.
1979a "Why is the Search for the Foundations of Ethics So Frustrating /~
Hastings Center Report 9: 16-22.
1979b "Social Science Methodology As the Ideology of Bureaucratic
Auth 0 rity 1/. Through the Looking Glas:Epistenzology and the C ollduct
of Enqllly : An Allthology (ed.) Maria J. Falco, University Press of
America,Washingtoll 42 - 58 .
1979c "The Poverty of Political Theory/~ London Review of Books 20:4,6.
1980a "A Crisis in Moral Philosophl: Knowing and Valuing the Search
for Common Root Hastings Center,Hasting-on-Hudsoll 18-35.
1980b "ConteA'ts of Interpretation:Reflections on Hans Geroge Gadamer's
Truth & Method", Boston University 10urna126: 173-76.
1980c "Ayer,Anscombe and Empiricism'/. London Review of Books 17: 15-16.
1980d "The Claims of Phi1osophl~ London Review of Books 5: 15 -16.
1981 a "The Nature of the Virtues:from Homer to Benjarrrin Franklin ". Hastings
Center Report, 11:27-34.
1982a "Philosophy, - other ~ Displines and Their Histories: a Rejoinder to
Richard Rorty ".Soundings 65 : 127- 45.
1982b "How Moral Agents Became Ghosts:or Why the History of Ethics Diverged
from That of the Philosophy of Miud'/ .Synthese 53:295,312.
1982c "Contemporary Moral Culture/I. Catholic Commission 011 Intellectual
alld Cultural Affairs Annual.Notre Dame:Catholic Commision on
Intellectual and Cultural Affairs,pp.26-34.
1982d "Public Virtue" . Londoll Review of Books 18: 14.
1983a Revisiolls:Changing Perpective ink/oral Philosoph ,edited by Stanley
Wauers.Notre Dame University Press.
1983b "The Indispensability of Political TheoIY" , in The Nature of Polilica!
The01y,ed. David Miller and Larry Sidentop. Oxford:Clarendon Press,
pp.17-33.
1983c "Moral Rationality,Tradition,and Aristotle: a Reply to Onora O'Neill,
Raimond Gaita,and Stephen R. L. Clark'/ . Inquiry 26:471-66.
198-1-a After Virtue:A Study in Moral Theory.2nd ed. Notre Dame: University
of Notre Dame Press.
1984b "Is Patriotism a Virtue? // (The Lindley Lecture, 1984 ).Lawrence:
Department of Philosophy, University OF Kansas.
1984c "Philosophy and Politics" ,in Philosophy and Human Enterprise,
USMA Class of 1951 Lecture Series pp.131-61.
1984d "The Relationship of Philosophy to Its Past" ,inPhilosophy in History
:Essays in the Historiography ofPhilosophy , ed. Richard Rorty,J. B.
Schneewind and Quentin Skinner. Cambridge:Cambridge University
Press,pp.31-48.
1985a "Rights,Practice and Marxism:Reply to Six Critics" .Analyse lind
Kritik 7:234-48.
1985b "How Psychology Makes Itself True or False" ,in A Centwyoj Psychology
As Signs,ed. Sigmunde Koch and Daniel E.Leary,Mcgraw Hill
New York,pp .897-903.
1986a "Which God Ought We to Obey and Why ? // Faith alldPhilosophy
3:59-71.
1986b "Practical Rationalities as Forms of Social Structure'/ . Irish
Philosophy JoumaI4 :3-19.
1987a "Philosophy:Past Conflict and Future Direction" .Proceedings and
Addresses oj the American Philosophical Association 61 : 81-7.
J 987b "Relativism, Power, and Philosphy" , in After Philosophy: End or
TronsjormatiOll?,ed. Kenneth Baynes,James Bohmam and Thomas
McCal1ily,Cambridge:MJT Press,pp.385 -41.
1988a Whose Justice? Which Rationality? Notre Dame:Univesity ofN otre
Dame Press.
1988b "Poetry as Political Philosophy;N otes on Burke and Yeats'/ , 111 Oil
lvlodem Poetry:Essays Presented to Donald Davie,ed.Verene Bell and
Laurence Lerner. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press,pp. 145 - 5 8.


1990a Three Rival Versions of Moral Enquiry:Encyclapaedia, Genealogy,
hadition.Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
1990b First Principles, Final Ends and Contemporary Philosophical Issues:
The Aquinas Lecture.Milwaukee:Marquette University Press.
1990c "The Forms of the Good, Traditions and Enquiry'" , in Value and UI1-
derstanding:Essays for Peter Winch, ed. Raimond Gaita,Rougledge,
London and New York,pp.242-62.
1990d "The Privatization of Good. An Inaugerallecture"'. Review of Politics
52:344-61.
1990e "Moral Dilemmas'/. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 50:
367-82.
1990f "Rejoinder to My Critics,Especially Soloman'/ . Reviell' of Politics 52:
375-77.
1991a "Nietzsche 0 Aristotele?// in COl1versa::iolli Americane,ed. G.
Bonadori,Editori Laterza,Roma-Bari,pp.169-87.
1991 b " Community,Law,and the Idiom and Rhetoric of Rights // . Listening
26:96-110.
1991 c "I'm not a Communitarian,But· .. ··· // . The ResponsiveCommul1ity
1(3):91-92.
1991 d "An Interview with Alasdair Macintyre'/ . Cogito 5(2):67 -73.
1991 e "Inconmmensurability , Truth, and the Conversation Between,
Coufucians and Aristotelians About the virtues '/ ,in Cultural and
Aiodernity : East West philosophic per-spectives , ed. Eliot Deutch,
Honolulu:University of Hawaii Press,pp.l04-22.
1992a "Plain Persons and Moral Philosophy : Rules , Virtues andGoods'/
American Catholoic Philosophical Quarterly 66:3-20.
1992b "vVhat Has not Happened in Moral Philosophy'/ . Yale Journal of
Criticism 5: 193-99.
1993 "Are Pbilosphical Problems Insoluble?:tl1e Relevance of System and
History" , in Philosophical Imagination and Cultural Memory:
Appropriating Historical Traditions, ed. Patricia Cook. Durham NC:
Duke University Press,pp.95-82.
1994 "A Partial Response to my Critics" , in After MacIntyre: Critical
Pespectives on the Work of Alasdair A1acIntyre , ed. by John Horton
and Susan Mendus.Cambridge:Polity Press,pp.283-304.
二、其他文獻
石元康
1987 < 二種道德觀一一試論儒家倫理的型態> ' { 儒家倫理研討
會論集》。新加坡:東亞哲學研究所, 232-50 。
1989 < 洛爾斯》。奎~t :東大。
1992a < 多神主義的困境> . { 當代) . 70: 16 一- 31 。
1992b <交堂,共識與民主社會政治學工作: 洛爾斯理論最近的發
展> . { 當代政治思?軒》。整:jt :民主基金會. 129 一
176 。
1993 < 自由與社會統一:德我肯論社群) , 臺:jt :中央研究院歐
美所〈第四屆美國文學與思想、學術研討會論文》
1995 < 社群與個體> . { 當代;) '114: 94 - 104 。
;工宣禪:
1994 < 政治社群與生命共同體一亞里斯多德、城邦理論的若干啟
示> ' 臺:j t : 中央研究院社科所《政治社群研討會》。
j工日新
1994 < 政治動物的「人格團結」及政治社群的構成:一個政治的哲
學人類學理解) ,臺北:中央研究院社科所《政治社群研討
會〉
(日)永井成男著,李樹琦(譯)
1992 ~分析哲學》。北京:社會科學出版社o
李秋零
1994 ~ 德國哲人j視野中的歷史》。北京:中國人民大學出版社。
陳俊宏
1995 <理解當代自由主義與社群主義的論爭:以公民資格為焦
點) ,東吳大學政治學研究所碩士論艾。
陳俊輝
1992 ~西洋哲學的古今〉。臺北:水牛出版社。
孫效智
1995 <道德論證問題在基本倫理學上的發展日的論與義務論之
爭) , {哲學與文化} , 22 (9) : 317-31 ~
林火日王
1994 < 自由主義可否建立一個社群?) ,臺北:中央研究院社科戶可
《政治社群研討會〉
黃進興
1992 { 歷史主義與歷史理論〉。臺:ft :允晨。
蕭高彥
1994 <愛國心與共同體政治認同之構成) ,臺北:中央研究院社科
所《政治社群研討會〉。
戴莘
1994 <羅爾斯論政治層面上的個人與社群) ,臺北:中央研究院社
科所《政治社群研討會》。
Beauchamp著,雷克勤等(譯)
1990 {哲學的倫理學》。北京:中國社會科學院出版社。
Collingwood著,黃宣範(譯)
1993 {歷史的理念〉。臺北: ~.微量。
Frankena著,黃慶明(譯)
1982 { 倫理學》。臺~t :雙葉書局。
Gray著,傅鐘等(譯)
1993 {自由主義)。臺北:桂冠。
MacIntyre著,龔群等(譯)
1995 {德性之后》。北京:中國社會科學出版社。
Tocqueville著,李宜培等(譯)
1985 {美國的民主〉。香港:今日世界社。
Aristotle
1975 Nicomachean Ethics,trans.by Hippocrates G. Apostle. GrinnelL
Iowa:Princeton University Press.
1984 Politics,trans. by Cames Lord. Chicago: ChicagoUniversity Press.
B ellab Robert, et. a1.
1985 Habits of the Heart:individualism and Commitment illAmericall
Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.
BonadOli, Giovanua
1994 " Nietzsche or Aristotle? : Alasdair MacIntyre!' , in Govanua
Barradori , The American Philosophy. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press,pp .137-152.
Buchaman , Allen, E.
1989 "Assessing the Communitarian Critique of Liberalisml/. Ethics 99:
852-82.
Caney , Simon
1992 "Liberalism and Communitarianism:A Misconceived Debatel/ .Po-
40:273 - 89.
Downing , Lyle & Thigon, Robert
1984 "After - Telos - :The Implication ofMacIntyre'sAttempt to Restore
the Concept in - After Virtue' ". Social Theory & Practice
10:39-54.
Dworkin , Ronald
1985 A lv/alter of Princeple .Cambridg,Mass:Harvard University Press.
1992 " Liberal Community'l, in Shlomo Avineri and Avner de-Shalit(ed.),
Communi tarianism and Individualism. Oxford: Oxford University
Press,pp .205-23.
Feldman, Susan
1986 "Objectivity,Pluralism and Relativism:A Critique of MacIntyre's
Theory of Virtue" .The Southern Journal of Philosophy 24:307-
20.
Frankena , William
1973 Ethics.Englewood Cliffs,N. 1. : Prentice-Hall.
1983 "Review of After Vinue" . Ethics 39 :579-87.
Frazer E. & Lacey N.
1994 "MacIntyre, Feminism and the Concept of Practice" ,in John
Horton and Susan Mendus( ed.),After IvfacIntyre:Critical Perspective
Oil Work of Alasdail' MacIntyre. Cambridge : Polity Press,pp .
265-82.
Gadamer , Hans-George
1975 Truth and Ivfe thod. New York:Seabury Press.
Gardbaum , Stephon A.
1992 "Law,Politics,and the Claims of Community" .MichigallLmv Review
90(4 ):685 -760.
Gewll1h , Alan

1985 "Rights and Virtue" . Review Metaphysics 38:739-62.
Gowen, C. W.
1982 "Review of After Virtue By Alasdair MacIntyre" .Intenlatioll
Philosophical Quarterly 92:216-40.
Gutmann, Amy
1992 "Communitarian Critics of Liberalism" ,in SWomoAvineri and
Avner de-Shalit (ed.) ,Communi/arianism and Individualism.
Oxford:Oxford University Press,pp.120- 36.
HabeIlllils Jurgen
1995 "Reconciliation Through the Public Use ofReason:Remarks on
Jolm Rawls's Political Liberalism" . TheJo71mal of Philosophy 92:
109-31.
Hare, R M.
1963 Freedom and Reason. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
Karl, R. Popper
1961 The Poverty of Historicism. London: Duclnv0l1h.
Kelly, Michael
1989-90 "Maclntyre,Habennas,and Philosophical Ethics" . The PhilosoKelly,
Paul
1994
Kolb , David
1986
phical Forum 21 :70-93.
"MacIntyre's Critique of Utilitarianism'/ ,in lollnHorton and
Susan Mendus( ed. ),After j\/!acJlltyre:Cri/ical Perspectives Oil the
Work of Alasdairlv!acJlltyre. Cambridge:Polity Press,pp.127-45.
The Critique of Pure /'v!oderl/ity. Chicago: The Universityof
Chicago Press.
Lukes, Steven
1973 Jndividualism.New York:Harper & Row Press.

Macpherson, C. B.
1962 The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism Hobbes to Locke.
Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Mason, Andrew
1994 "MacIntyre on Liberalism and it's Critics: Tradition, Incommensurability
and Disagreement'/ ,in John Hortonand Susan Mendus
(ed.), After MacIntyre: CriticalPerspectives on the Work of
Alasdair MacIntyre. Cambridge: Polity Press,pp.205-24.
McMylor, P.
1994 Alasdair IvlacIntyre Critic of l'v1odernity. London: Routledge &
Kegan Paul.
Miller, David
1994 "Virtues,Practices and Justice'/, in John Horton and Susan Mendus
(ed. ),After lv!acJntyre:CriticaIPerspective all the Work of Alasdair
lv/acilltyre. Cambridge:Polity Press,pp.245-64.
Mouffe , Chantal
1993 The Return of Political. London & New Y ork:verso.
Mulhall & Swift
1992 Liberalism and Communitarianism.Oxford:Basil Blacbvell.
Nagel, Thomas
1975 "Rawls on Justicel/ ,in Norman,Daniels(ed.),Readillg Rawls:Crifical
Studies of a TheOlY of Justice. New York: Basic Books Inc,
pp.I-15.
Nelson, Paul
1987 Narrative and lv!orality:A Theologicallllqlliry. ThePennsylvania
State University Press.
O'N eill Onora
1983 "Kant After Virtue 1/, Inquiry 26:387-405.


Rawls, John
1971 A Theory of Justice. Harverd:Harverd University Press.
1993 Political Liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press.
1995 "Reply to Habermash" . Journal of Philosophy 92: 142-58.
Rorty , Richard
1991 Objectivity Relativism, and Truth. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Sandel, Michael
1982 Liberalism and the Limits of Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge
University PTess.
1992 "The Procedural Republic and Unencumbered Self" , in Shlomo
Avineri and Avner de-Shalit( ed.),Comm21nitarianism and lndividualism.
Oxford: Oxfo rd University Press,pp: 12-28.
Scheffler, Samuel
1983 "Book Review:After Yirtue'/ .The Philosophical Review92:443 -
47.
Schlleewind , 1. B.
1982 " Yirtue,Narrative and Cornmllnity:MacIntyre andMorality/~ JourlIal
of Philosophy 79:653 - 63 .
Solomon, David
1990 " Comment on MacIntyTe" . The Review of Politics 52:369-74.
Taylor, Charles
1975 Hegel. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
1985 Philosophy and Human Science: Philosophical Paper V: 2. Carublidge:
Cambridge University Press.
Wachbroit R.
1983 "A Genealogy ofYutues// . The Yale Lmv Journal 92:564-76.
Wallace Jay
1989 "Review of After YUille and Whose Justice?Wbich Rationality?
by A. MacIntyre II . H;story 28:337.
Wallach, John ;
1992 "Contemporary Aristotelianisml
! .PolWeal Theory 20 : 613 -4l.
Wartofsky , Marx
1984 "Virtue Lost or Understanding MacIntyre I! . Inquiry 27:235- 50.
Description: 碩士
國立政治大學
政治學系
81252012
Source URI: http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#B2002002700
Data Type: thesis
Appears in Collections:[政治學系] 學位論文

Files in This Item:

File SizeFormat
index.html0KbHTML120View/Open


All items in 學術集成 are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.


社群 sharing