1. NCCU Academic Hub
  2. 學術產出
  3. College of Education
  4. Theses
  5. Item

學術產出-Theses

Article View/Open

Publication Export

Google ScholarTM

政大圖書館

Citation Infomation

  • No doi shows Citation Infomation
題名 中小學生批判思考及其相關因素之研究
作者 葉玉珠
貢獻者 吳靜吉
葉玉珠
日期 1991
1990
上傳時間 2-May-2016 17:12:22 (UTC+8)
摘要 本研究旨在了解中小學生批判思考能力之現況，並探討批判思考與其前置變項及後果變項之關係，接以提出建議。本研究首先探討性別、年級、城鄉別、認知風格(場地獨立)及動機等前置變項與批判思考的關係；其次探討批判思考與學業成就(後果變項)之關係；然後探討性別、城鄉別、智力、認知風格及動機與批判思考的典型相關，最後提出建議，以供批判思考教學及研究之參考。
參考文獻 參考書目
     一、中文參考書目:
     了振豐(民76) 。學生場地獨立性與教學方法的交互作用對認知及情意學習效果之影響。師大輔導研究所碩士論文。
     王連生(民77) 。教育哲學研究。台北:五南圖書公司。
     中華技術院(民71) 。中文大辭典第四?。台北:文化大學出版部。
     孔令信(民72) 。巴斯卡:思考的蘆葦。台北:時報文化出版社。
     朱敬先(民77) 。教育心理學。台北:五南圖書社。
     江方盛(民79) 。高雄市國民小學教師批判思考教學行為之研究。師大碩士論文。
     李英明(民75) 。哈伯瑪斯。台北:東大圖書公司。
     李德高(民77) 。教育心理學。台北:五南圖書公司。
     倪鳴香(民70) 。幼兒創造力發展及其相關因素之研究。文化大學碩士論文。
     林玉體(民77) 。西洋教育史。台北:文景出版社。
     林清江(民69) 。我國中小學公民教育內涵及實施成效之研究。台北:行政院研考會。
     林清江(民70) 。教育社會學新論。台北:五南圖書公司。
     林瑞榮(民77) 。小學社會課程的發展趨勢及其啟示。師大碩士論文。
     韋政通(民73) 。中國哲學思想批判。台北:水牛出版社。
     柯華葳、秦葆琦(民75) 。中國見童政治行為研究。板橋:省國教教師研習會。
     唐華著(民70) 。中國理則學與西洋邏輯。台北:大中國圖書公司。
     許在世(民75) 。國民小學社會科教學現況及改進途徑之研究。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     張玉成(民78) 。教師發問技巧。台北:心理出版社。
     張守泰(民66) 。前導架構短文與認知型式對閱讀成績的影響。攻大教育研究所碩士論文。
     張春興，林清山(民75) 。教育心理學。台北:東華書局。
     張春典(民76) 。心理學概要。台北:東華書局。
     張春典(民78) 。張氏心理學辭典。台北:東華書局。
     郭生玉(民77) 。心理與教育測驗。台北:精華書局。
     黃公偉(民58) 。哲學概論。台北:帕米爾圖書公司。
     黃正鵠(民73) 。精神分析基本理論。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     溫世頌(民76) 。教育心理學。台北:三民書局。
     陳中人譯(民78) 。現象學與哲學的危機。台北:結構群出版社。
     陳曉林(民79) 。壯歲旌旗。台北:時報文化出版企業有限公司。
     陳伯璋(民76) 。潛在課程研究。台北:五南圖書公司。
     陳慶文(民59) 。學習心理學。台北:台灣書店。
     郭為藩(民76) 。科技時代的人文教育。台北:幼獅圖書公司。
     游恆山譯(民76) 。實用思考指南。台北:遠流出版社。
     項退結(民77) 。邁向未來的哲學思考。台北:東大圖書公司。
     程炳林(民80) 。國民中小學生激勵的學習策略之相關研究。政大碩士論文。
     楊莉容譯(民79) 。皮亞傑。台北:桂冠圖書公司。
     楊銀典(民76) 。國小學生場地獨立性、內外控信念與道德判斷的關係。師大教育研究所碩士論文。
     廖元輝譯(民77) 。思維心理學。台北:五洲出版社。
     編輯小組(民70) 。教育哲學。台北:文景出版社。
     劉伯明譯(民62) 。思維術。台北:華崗出版社。
     劉德勝(民76) 。小學社會科課程結構與內涵。高雄:復文圖書公司
     齊隆鯤(民76) 。諮商投術與策略。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     歐用生、林瑞欽(民75) 。價值澄清法。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     歐用生(民78) 。課程與教學--概念、理論與實際。台北:文景出版社。
     歐陽教(民71) 。道德判斷與道德教學。台北:文景出版社。
     鍾聖校(民79) 。認知心理學。台北:心理出版社。
     葉學志(民73) 。教育哲學。台北:三民書局。
     籃順德(民75) 。公民教育的內涵。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     二、中文參考期刊:
     毛連溫、劉燦梁、陳麗華(民80) 。康乃爾批判思考測驗之修訂。
     中國測驗學會測驗年刊，第38輯，頁109-123 。
     江芳盛(民78) 。為甚麼要教導學生思考。現代教育，第四卷，第四期，頁145-153 。
     成中英(民72) 。啟盟運動中理性角色的反省與自覺。中國論壇，第十六卷，第三期，頁7-8 。
     吳靜吉等(民68) 。場地獨立性的發展及其相關因素之研究。教育與心理研究，第三期，頁118-139 。
     吳靜吉(民79) 0 未發表之講義。
     林玉體(民76) 。談邏輯解析與思考教學。現代教育，第二卷，第三期，頁63-70 。
     柯麗儀、周麗玉(民78) 。躍吉斯與你--真誠、尊重與同理的暸解。
     諮商與輔導，第39期，頁45-46。
     胡夢鯨(民77) 。從思想研究的本質與步驟談「回歸原典」的必要性。現代教育，第三卷，第二期，頁150-161 。
     高廣孚(民76) 。哲學分析與教學研究。現代教育，第二卷，第二期，頁43-62 。
     陳伯璋(民79) 。哈伯瑪斯「批判解釋學」及其對課程研究的啟示。
     師大教育研究所集刊，第24輯，頁73-131 。
     陳麗華(民78) 。國小社會科批判思考教學的省思。現代教育，第七卷，第15期，頁121-135 。
     張春興(民77) 。知之歷程與教之歷程:認知心理學的發展及其在教育上的應用。教育心理學報，第21期，頁17-18 。
     歐陽教(民53) 。康德的哲學與教育思想。師大教研所集刊，第七集，頁242 。
     歐陽教(民76) 。教學的哲學分析。現代教育，第二卷，第二期，頁32-41 。
     蘇永明(民69) 。杜威的教育哲學。今日教育，第38期，頁69-73。
     三、英文參考書目
     Baron, J., Badgio, P. C. & Gaskins, I. W. (1986). Cognitive
     styles and its improvement: a normative approach. In R. J.
     Sternberg (ed.) Advances In the psychology of human
     intelligence. Broadway: Lawrence Erlbaum Association, Inc.
     Baron, J. B. & Sternberg, R. J. (1986). Teaching thinking
     skills: theory and practice. New York: W. H. Freeman
     Company.
     Bastein, C. (1985). A developmental model of problem solving.
     In G`ery d`YDEWALLE (ed.) Cognition. information
     processing. and motivation. Emsterdam: Elsevier Science
     Publishing Company.
     Beck, R. C . (1983) . Motivation: theories and principles..
     Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall. Inc.
     Beyer, B. K. (1988b). Developing a thinking skills program.
     Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Inc.
     Borkowski. J. G. & Krause. A. J. (1985). Metacognition and
     attributional beliefs. In G`ery d`YDEWALLE (ed.) Cognjtion.
     information processing. and motivation. Emsterdam: Elsevier
     Science Pulishing Company.
     Brookfield. S. D. (1987). Developing critical thinkers:
     challenge adults to explore alternative ways of thinking
     actjng. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
     Connerton. P. (1978). Critical sociology. Harmondsworth:
     Penguin Press.
     Dewey. J. (1910). How we think. Boston: Heath.
     Ennis. R. H. (1985b). Goals for a critical thinking
     curriculum. In A. L. Costa (ed.) Developing minds: a
     resource book for teaching Thinking. Virginia: ASCD.
     
     Ennis. R. H., Millman, J. & Tomko, T . N . (1985) . Cornell
     critical thinking tests level X & level Z-Manual. CA:
     Midwest Publications.
     Ennis, R. H. (1987). A taxonomy of critical thinking
     dispositions and abilities. In J. B. Baron & R. J. Sternberg
     (eds.) Teaching thinking skills: theory and practice. New
     York: W. H. Freeman Company.
     Evans. J. St B.T. (1983). Thinking and reasoning. London:
     Routledge & Kegan Paul.
     Freeman, W. H. (1986). Teaching thinking skills: theory and
     practice. In J. B. Baron & R. J. Sternberg (eds.) Teaching
     thinking skills: Theory and practice. New York: W. H.
     Freeman Company.
     Goldstein, K. M. & Blackman, S. (1978). Cognitive style.
     Ohio: John Wiley & Son. Inc.
     Grant. G. E. (1988). Teaching critical thinking. New York:
     Praeger Publishers.
     Hoffman, M. L. (1986). Affect-cognition and motivation. In
     R. M. Sorrentino & E. T. Huggins (eds.) Handbook of
     motivation and cognition. New York: Guilford Publication.
     Hudgins. B. B. (1977). Learning & teaching-a prImer for
     teachers. Illinois: F. E. Peacock Publishers, Inc.
     Kuhl, J. & Wassijew, I. (1985). An information processing
     perspective on motivation: intrinsic task-involvement,
     problem solving, and the complexity of action plans. In
     G`ery d`YDEWALLE (ed. ) Cognition. information processing.
     and motivation. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishing
     Company.
     Kuhl. J & Atkinson. J. W. (1986). Motivation. thought. and
     action. New York: Praeger Publishers.
     Kuhl. J. & Geiger. E. (1986). The dynamic theory of the
     anxiety allocation. In J. kuhl & J. W. Atkinson (eds.)
     Motivatjon. TbOUght. and Action. New York : Praeger
     Publishers. New York: Praeger Publishers.
     Kuhl. J. & Blankenship. (1989). The dynamic theory of
     achievement motovation: from episodic to dynamic thinking.
     In J. Kuhl & J. `W. Atkinson (eds. ) Motivation. thought.
     and action. New York: Praeger Publishers.
     Kuhl. J. (1986). Motivation and information processing: a
     new look at decision making, dynamic change, and action
     Control. In R. M. Sorrentino & E. T. Higgins (eds.)
     Handook of motivation and cognition. New York: Guilford
     Publication.
     Mayer. R. E. (1987). educational psychology: a cognitive
     approach. Boston: Little. Brown and Company.
     Mckeachie. `W. J .? Pintrich. P. R. & Lin. Y. (1985). Learn to
     learn. In G`ery d`YOEWALLE (ed.) Cognition. information
     processing. and motivation. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science
     Publishing Company.
     Mctighe, J. & Schollonberger. J. (1985). Why teach thinking:
     a statement of rationale. In A. L. Costa (eds.)
     Developing Minds. U. S. : The Association for Supervision &
     Curriculum Development.
     Neimark. E. D. (1987). Advantures In thinking. Orlando:
     Harcourt `Brace Jovanovich. Inc.
     Nickerson. R. S .. Perkins. D. N .. & Smith. E. E. (1985). The
     teaching of thinking. Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum
     Associates. Publishers.
     Nickerson, R. S. (1986). Reasoning. In R. F. Dillion & R. J.
     Sternberg (eds.) Cognition and instruction. California:
     Academic Press, Inc.
     Norris, S. P. & and Ennis R. H. (1989). Evaluating critical
     thinking. C. A. : Midwest Publications.
     Ozman, H. A.& Craver, S. M. (1986). Philosophical
     foundations of education. Columbus: A Brell &Howell
     Paul. R. (1990b). Critical thinking: What every person needs
     to survive in a rapidly changing world. C.A.: Center for
     Critical Thinking and Morale Critique.
     Pintrich, P. R. (1988). A process-oriented View or student
     motivation and cognition. In J. S. Stark & L. Mets (eds.)
     Improving teaching and learning through research. San
     Francisco: Jessy-Bass.
     Pintrich. P. R. (1989). The dynamic interplay of student
     motivation and cognition in the college classroom. In C.
     Ames & M. Machr (eds.) Advences In motivation and
     achievement. Grinwich: TAI Press.
     Pressisen. B. Z.(1985). Thinking skills: meaning and models.
     In Costa. A. L.(ed.) Developing minds: a resource book
     for teaching thinking. Virginia: ASCD.
     Raynor, J. O. & Mcfarlin, (1986). Motivation and the Self-system.
     In R. M. Sorrentino(ed.) Handbook of motivation
     and Cognition. New York: Guilford Publication.
     Ruggiero, V. R. (1988). Teaching thinking across the
     curriculum. New York: Happer & Row Publishers.
     Scheffler, I. (1973). Reason and teaching. London: Routhedge
     and Kagan Paul .
     Siegel, H. (1988). Educating reason: rationality, critical
     thinking and education. London: Roulthedge.
     Siegler, R. S. (1986). Children`s thinking. Englewood Cliffs:
     Prentice-Hall. Inc.
     Smith, R. M. (1982). Learning how to learn. Cambridge: The
     Adult Education Company.
     Sternberg. R. (1985a). Critical thinking: its nature,
     measurement, and improvement. In R. L. Frances (ed.)
     Essays on the Intellect. Virginia: ASCD.
     Sternbeg, R. (1986). Cognition and instruction: why the
     marriage sometimes ends in divorce. In R. F. Dillion & R.
     J. Sternberg (eds.) Cognition and instruction. California:
     Academic Press. Inc.
     Witkin, H. A. (1978). Cognitive styles in personal cultural
     adapt ion. Clark University Press.
     Yinger. R. J. (1980). Can We really teach them to think? In
     R. E. Young (ed.) Eorstering critical thinking. San
     Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
     Young, R. E. (1980). Editor`s notes: critical thinking--a
     renewed interest. In R. E. Young (ed.) Forstering Critical
     Thinking. San Fracisco: Jossey-Bass.
     四、英文參考期刊：
     Alexander, P. A., Willson, V. L., White, C. S. & Fuqua, J. D.
     (1987). Analogical reasoning in young children. Journal of
     Educational Psychology. 79(4). 401-408.
     Annis, L. F. (1979). Effect of cognitive style and learning
     passage organization on study technique effectiveness.
     Journal of Educational Psychology, 71(5). 620-626.
     Arnold G. H. Hart, A. & Campbell. K. (1988). Introducing the
     Wednesday revolution. Educatjonal Leadership, 45(7), 48.
     Barell, J., Liebmann. R. & Sigel, I. (1988).Forstering
     thoughtful self-direction in students, Educational
     Leardership. 45(7), 14-17.
     Baxter, M. & Marcia, B. (1987).Gender differences in
     cognitive development. Paper presented at the Annual
     Meeting of the American Educational Research Association
     Washington.DC .
     Batcheller, M F. (1985). Implementing a critical thinking
     skills program in the social studies curriculum K-12
     Educational leadership, 42(8), 46.
     Beyer, B. K. (1983) . Commen sense about teaching thinking
     skills. Educational Leadership. 41(3), 44-49.
     Beyer, B. K. (1985a). Critical thinking: What is it? Social
     Education, 49(4), 270-276.
     Beyer, B. K. (1985b). Teaching critical thinking: a direct
     approach. Social Education. 49(4), 297-303.
     Beyer, B. K. (1985c). Critical thinking revisited. Social
     Education, 49(4), 268-269.
     Beyer, B. K. (1988a). Developing a scope and sequence for
     skills instruction. Educational Leadershjp, 45(7), 26-30.
     Biggs, J. B. (1978). Individual and group differences in
     study processes. British Journal of Educational Psychology,
     4a(3). 266-279.
     Bitner. C & Betty, L. (1988) . Logical and critical
     thinking abilities of sixth through twelfth grade students
     and formal reasonlng modes as predictors of critical
     thinking abilities and academic achievement. Paper
     presented at the Annual Meeting of the National
     Association for Research in `Science Teaching. Lake of the
     Ozarks, MO.
     Brandt. R. S. (1985). On creativity and thinking skills: a
     coversation with David Perkins. Educational Leadership, 43
     (4). 12-13.
     Brell. C. D. (1990). Critical- thinking . as transfer: the
     reconstructive integration of otherwise discrete
     interpretations of experience. Educational Theory, 40(1),
     53-85.
     Brown. L.E .. & Cook, E. (1975). How children`s interests
     affect their critical thinking ability. Educational
     Leadership. 32(5). 339-342.
     Bussey, K. & Maughan, B. (1982). Gender difference in
     reasoning. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
     42(4). 701-706.
     Derrico, P. J. (1988). Learning to think with philosophy for
     children. Educational Leadership, 45(7), 34.
     Diamond. I. D. (1977). Resistence to change: relationship of
     personality and cognitive innovation diffusion process.
     Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the College
     Reading Association. Cincinati, Ohi.
     Doherty, D. C. (1990). Using corporate-sponsored materials
     to teach history and social science skills. Educational
     Leadership, 47(4). 81-83.
     Doolittle, A. & Welch. C. (1989). Gender differences in
     performance on the college-level achievement test. Paper
     presented at the Annual Meeting of the American
     Educational Research Association. San Fracisco, CA.
     Doyle, W. & Cater, K. (1984). Academic tasks In classroom.
     Curricylum Inquiry, 14(2), 139-149.
     Dunkin, M. J. & Doenau, S. J,. (1980). A replication study
     of unique and Joint contributions to variance In student
     achievement. 72(3). 394-403.
     Echeverria, E. (1990). Learning and using critical thinking.
     Unpublished paper in Philosophy for Children: East and
     West, 1-13.
     Ehri, L. C. & Muzio. I. M. (1974). Cognitive style and
     reasoning about speed. Journal of Educational Psychology,
     66,569-571.
     Ennis. R. H. (1962). A concept of critical thinking. Harvard
     Educatjoal Review, 32(1), 81-111.
     Ennis. R. H. (1985a). A logical basis for measuring critical
     thinking skills. Educational Leadershjp, 43(2), 45-48.
     Ennis, R. H. (1985c). Critical thinking and the curriculum.
     Phi Kappa Phi Journal. 65(1), 28-31.
     Farrar, M. T. (1986). Four conceptions of literacy. Reading
     Psychology, 7(1). 43-55.
     Flexer. B. K. & Roberge, J. J. (1983). A longitudinal
     investigation of field dependence-independence and the
     development of formal operatinal thought. British Journal
     of Educational Psychology, 53(part 2) 195-204.
     Frank. B. M. (1984). Effect of independence-dependence and
     study technique on learning from a lecture. American
     Educational Research. 3(21), 669-678.
     Fridman, G. H .. Lehrer, B. E. & Stevens. J. P. (1983). the
     effectiveness of self-directed and lecture/ discussion
     stresss management approaches and the locus of control of
     teacher. American Educational Research Journal, 20(4), 563-
     580.
     Garett. K., & Wulf, K. (1978). The relationship of a measure
     of critical thinking ability to personality variables and
     to indicators of academic achievement. Educational and
     Psychological Measurement, 38(4), 1181-1187.
     Gibbs, J. C. et ale (1986) . Relations between moral
     judgement. moral courage. and field independence. Child
     Development. 57(1). 185-193
     Hansson, S. B .. Ryden. D. D., & Johnsson. P. (1986). field-dependence/
     independence: ability in relation to mobility-fixity.
     Perceptual and Motor Skills. 63(1. part1). 279-293.
     Hawly, W. D. (1988). Missing pieces of the educational
     reform agenda: or. why the first and second waves may miss
     the boat. Educational Administration Quarterly. 24(4). 416-
     437.
     Hertzberg, H. (1988). Foundations. Social Education. 52(2).
     144-145.
     --- 193 "-`
     Hoogstraten, J .. & Christiaans. H. H. C. M. (1975). The
     relationship of the watson-glaser critical` thinking
     appraisal to sex and four selected personality measures
     for a sample of Dutch first-year psychology students.
     Educatjonal and Psychological Measurement, 35(4). 969-973.
     Hudgins. B. B.,& Edelman. S. (1986) . Teaching critical
     skills to fourth and fifth grades through critical teacher-lead
     small-group disscussions. Journal of Educational?
     Research. 79(6). 333-342.
     Hudgins. B. B.. & Edelman. S. (1988). Children `s self-directed
     critical thinking. The Journal of Educational
     Research.81(5). 262-273.
     Hudgins. B. B .? Riesenmy. M, Ebel, D. & Edelman. S. (1989) .
     Children`s critical thinking: a model for its analysis and
     two examples. Educational Research. 82(6). 327-338.
     Hurov. J. T. (1987). A study of the relationship between
     reading. computational. and critical thinking skills and
     academic success in fundamental of chemistry. Research
     report.
     Johnson, D. W. & Johnson. R. T. (1987). Research shows the
     benefits of adult cooperation. Educational Leadership. 45
     (3). 27-30.
     Kagan. S. & Zahn. G. L. (1982). Generalized maternal
     reinforcement and children`s reading achievement. math
     achievement and field independence. The Journal of Genetic
     Psychology. 141. 93-104.
     Knight. S. L .. Waxman. H. C. And Padron. Y. N. (1989) .
     Students` perceptions of relationships between social
     studies instruction and cognitive strategies. Educational
     Research. 82(5). 270-276.
     Kownslar, A. O. (1985). What`s worth having students think
     critical about? Social Education, 49(4), 304-307.
     Kulleseid, E. R. (1986). Extending the research base: schema
     theory, cognitive styles, and types of intelligence. School
     Library Media Quartlv, 15(1), 41-48.
     Lundeberg, M. A. & Fox, P. W. (1991) . Do laboratory
     findings on test _expectancy generalize to classroom
     outcomes? Review of Educational Research. 62(1), 94-106.
     McCamon, S. et al. (1988). Predicting course performance In
     freshman and sophomore physics courses: women are more
     predictabIe the men. Journal od Research in Science
     Teaching, 25(6), 501-510.
     Manning, B. H., & Payne, B. D. (1989). A cognitive self-direction
     model for teacher education. Journal of Teacher
     Education, 4Q(3) , 27-32.
     McCammon, S et al. (1988). Predicting course performance In
     freshman and sophomore physics courses: women are more
     predictable than men. Journal of Research in Science
     Teaching, 25(6), 501-510.
     McDonald, E. R. (1984). The relationship of student and
     faculty field dependence/independence congruence to
     student academic achievement. Educational and Psychological
     Measurement, 44, 725-731.
     McFarland. M . A. (1985). Critical thinking in elementary
     school social studies. Social Educatjon, 49(4). 277-280.
     McMillan. J. H. (1987). Enhancing college students` critical
     thinking: a review of studies. Research in Higher Education.
     26(1), 3-19.
     McPeck, J. E. (1984). Stalking beasts. but swatting flies:
     the teaching of critical thinking. Canadian Journal of
     Education, 9(1), 28-44.
     Michalak. S. J. (1986). Enhancing critical thinking skills
     in traditional liberal arts courses: report on a faculty
     workshop. Liberal Education, 72(3), 253-261.
     Mirrnan, J. & Tiahman S. (1988). Infusing thinking through
     connections". Educational Leadership, 4:5(7), 64-65.
     Nenitto, J. & Strickland, J. (1987). Critical thinking: a
     skill for all seasons. College Student Journal, 21(2), 201-
     204.
     Newton, B. T. (1978). Theoretical bases for higher cognitive
     questioning-an avenue to critical thinking. Education, 98
     (3), 286-291.
     Niaz. M. & Lawson, A. E. (1985) . Balancing chemical
     equations: the role of developmental level and mental
     capacity. Journal of Research in Science Teaching,22(1),
     41-51.
     Niaz,M. (1987) .Mobility-flexity dimension in Witkin’s
     theory of field-dependence/ independence and its
     Motor: Skills. 65(3),755-764.
     Niaz, M. (1989). The role of cognitive style and its
     influence on proportional reasoning. Perceptual and Motor
     Skills, 26(3). 221-235.
     Norris, S. P. (1985). Synthesis of research on critical
     thinking. Educational Leadership, 42(8), 40-45.
     Norris, S. P., & Phillips, L. M. (1987) . Explanations of
     reading comprehension: schema theory and critical thinking
     theory. Teachers College Record, 89(2). 281-306.
     Norris. S. P. (1988). Research needed on critical thinking.
     Canadjan Journal of Education. 13(1). 125-137.
     Overton. W. , Byrnes. J. P ., & O`brien, D. P. (1985).
     Developmental and individual differences In conditional
     reasoning: the role of contradition training and cognitive
     style. Developmental Psychology, 21(4). 692-701.
     Paradise. L. V & Block. C. (1984). The relationship of
     teacher-student cognitive style to academic achievement.
     Journal of Research and Development and Education. 17(4),
     57-61.
     Paul. R. H. (1984). Critical thinking: fundamental to
     education for a free society. Educational Leadership, 42
     (1). 4-14.
     Pau 1. R. W. (1985). Bloom`s Taxonomy and critical
     instruction. Educational Leadership. 42(8). 36-39.
     Paul. R. W. & Adamson. K. R. (1990). Critical thinking and
     the nature of prejudice. Paper presented at The 10th
     Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking and
     Educational Reform, 1-48.
     Pierce, W., Lemke. E., & Smith. R. (1988). Critical thinking
     and moral development in secondary students. The High
     School Journal. 71(3). 120-126.
     Pintrich, P. R. (1986). Motivation and learning strategies
     interactions with achievement. Paper presented at the
     American Educational Reserch Association Convention. San
     Francisco. California. 1-19.
     Pintrich, P. R. (1987). Motivated learning strategies in the
     college classroom. Paper presented at the American
     Educational Research Association Convention, Washington,D.
     C. 1-38.
     Pogrow, S. (1988). Teaching thinking to at-risk elementary
     students. Educational Leadership, 45(7), 79-85.
     Roach, D. A. (1985). Effects of cognitive style,
     intelligence, and sex on reading achievement. Perceptual
     And Motor Skills, 51(3, part 2),1139-1142.
     Rornanish, B. (1986). Critical thinking and the curriculum: a
     critique. The Educational Forum, 51(1), 45-55.
     Ronning, R.R., Mccurdy, D. & Ballinger, R. (1984).
     Individual defferences: a third component in problem-solving
     instruction. Journal of Research in Science
     Teaching, 21(1), 71-82.
     Sadler, W. A., & Whimbey, A. (1985). A holistic approach to
     improving thinking skills. Phi Delta Kappan, 67(2),199-203.
     Saracho, O. N. & Dayton, C. M. (1980). Relationship of
     teachers` cognitive styles to pupils` academic achievement
     gains. Journal of Educational Psychology, 72(4), 544-549.
     Sasseville, M. (1990). Chapter one of Harry Stottlemeier’s
     discovery: a cl:ucible integratol: of critical and creative
     thinking. Paper presented at the Philosophy for Children
     East and West, 1-5.
     Shelly, A. C. & Willam, W. W. (1988). Sex equity and critical
     thinking. Social Education, 52(3), 168-173.
     Shulk, J. P. (1987). Knowledge and teaching: foundations of
     the new reform. Harvard Educational Review, 57(1), 1-22.
     Shulk. J. P. (1988). Project IMPACT in elementary school.
     Educational Leadership, 45(7), 41.
     Siegel, H. (1980). Critical thinking as an educational
     ideal. The Educational Forum, 45(1), 7-23.
     Smith. D. G. (1977) . College classroom Interactions and
     critical thinking. Journal of Educational Psychology, 69
     (2). 180-190.
     Solomon, S. J. & Wurster. S. R. (1978). Correlations between
     critical thinking achievement and scholastic aptitude In
     high school seniors. Research report.
     Sternberg. R. J. (1984) . How can we teach intelligence?
     Educatjonal Leadership, 42(1), 38-50.
     Sternberg, R. J. (1985a) . A statewide approach to
     measuring critical thinking skills. Educational Leadership,
     43(2), 40-43.
     Sternberg, R. J. (1985b). Teaching critical thinking, part 1:
     are we making critical mistakes? Phi Delta Kappan. 67(3),
     194-198.
     Sternberg, R. J. (1985c). Teaching criticl thinking. part 2:
     possible solutions. Phi Delta Kappan, 67(4), 277-280.
     Steward. R. J. & AI-Abdulla. Y. (1989). An examination of
     the relationship between critical thinking and academic
     success on a university campus. Research report.
     Tabor. M. (1988). Better student thinking through changing
     teacher behaviors. Educational Leadership, 45.(7), 49-51.
     Thomas, C. R. (1983a). Field independence and myers-briggs
     thinking individuals. Perceptual and Motor Skills. 57(3.
     part 1), 790.
     Thomas, C. R . (1983b). Fie 1 d independence and technical
     achivement. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 57(3, part 1). 858.
     WaIsh, D. (1988). Critical thinking to reduce prejudice.
     Social Education, 52(4), 280-282.
     Walters, K. S. (1986) . Critical thinking in liberal
     education: a case of overkill ? Liberal Education, 72(3),
     233-244.
     Walters, k. S. (1989) . Critical thinking in teacher
     education: towards a demythologization. Journal of Teacher
     Education, 40(3) , 14-19.
     Welkowitz, L. A., & Calkins, R. p. (1984) . Effects of
     cognitive and exemplar modeling on field depencdnce-independence.
     Perceptual and Motor Skills, 58(2, part 2),
     439-442.
     WiIIams, B. (1987). Implementing thinking skills instruction
     in an uban district: an effect to close the gap. Educational
     Leadership, 44(6), 50-53.
     White, C. S. & Fuqua, J. D. (1987). Analogical reasoning in
     young children .. Journal of Educational Psychology, 79(4).
     401-408.
     Witkin, H. A. & Goodenough, D. R. (1977). Field-dependent
     and field-independent cognitive styles. Review of
     Educational Research, 47(1), 1-64.
     Witkin, H. A. et al. (1977) . Field-dependent and Field-independent
     cognitive styles and their educational
     implications. Review of Educational Research. 47(1), 1-64.
     Wolfle, L. M. & Robertshaw, D. (1982) . Effects of college
     attendence on locus of control. Journal od Personality and
     Social psychology, 43(4), 802-810.
     Worsham. A. W. & Austin, G. R. (1984). Effects of teaching
     Thinking skills on SAT scores, 41(3), 50-51.
     Zenke. L. & Alexander, L. (1984). Teaching thinking in Tulsa.
     Educational Leadershjp. 42(1), 81-84.
描述 碩士
國立政治大學
教育學系
資料來源 http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#B2002005006
資料類型 thesis
dc.contributor.advisor 吳靜吉zh_TW
dc.contributor.author (Authors) 葉玉珠zh_TW
dc.creator (作者) 葉玉珠zh_TW
dc.date (日期) 1991en_US
dc.date (日期) 1990en_US
dc.date.accessioned 2-May-2016 17:12:22 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.available 2-May-2016 17:12:22 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.issued (上傳時間) 2-May-2016 17:12:22 (UTC+8)-
dc.identifier (Other Identifiers) B2002005006en_US
dc.identifier.uri (URI) http://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/89888-
dc.description (描述) 碩士zh_TW
dc.description (描述) 國立政治大學zh_TW
dc.description (描述) 教育學系zh_TW
dc.description.abstract (摘要) 本研究旨在了解中小學生批判思考能力之現況，並探討批判思考與其前置變項及後果變項之關係，接以提出建議。本研究首先探討性別、年級、城鄉別、認知風格(場地獨立)及動機等前置變項與批判思考的關係；其次探討批判思考與學業成就(後果變項)之關係；然後探討性別、城鄉別、智力、認知風格及動機與批判思考的典型相關，最後提出建議，以供批判思考教學及研究之參考。zh_TW
dc.description.tableofcontents 目次
     第一章 緒論....................1
     第一節 研究動機與目的....................1
     第二節 研究問題、研究假設與研究架構....................7
     第三節 研究範凰與限制....................10
     第二章 文獻探討....................15
     第一節 批判思考之探討....................15
     第二節 性別、年級、城鄉別與批判思考之關係....................41
     第三節 認知風格與批判思考之關係....................46
     第四節 動機與批判思考之關係....................53
     第五節 批判思考與學業成就之關係....................59
     第三章 研究方法....................68
     第一節 研究對象....................68
     第二節 研究工具....................69
     第三節 實施程序....................72
     第四節 統計處理....................73
     第四章 研究結果....................75
     第一節 性別、年級、城鄉別與批判思考之關係....................75
     第二節 認知風格與批判思考之關係....................89
     第三節 動機與批判思考之關係....................94
     第四節 批判思考與學業成就之關係....................102
     第五節 性別、城鄉別、智力、認知風格及動機與批判思考之關係.................... 110
     第五章 討論與建議.................... 115
     第一節 討論....................115
     第一節 建議.................... 130
     附錄....................135
     附錄一康乃爾批判思考測驗之修訂....................135
     附錄二康乃爾批判思考測驗....................163
     附錄三性別、城鄉別、智力、認知風格、動機及批判思考與學業成就之關係....................173
     附錄四本研究所有變項之相關矩陣....................178
     參考書目....................181		zh_TW
dc.source.uri (資料來源) http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#B2002005006en_US
dc.title (題名) 中小學生批判思考及其相關因素之研究zh_TW
dc.type (資料類型) thesisen_US
dc.relation.reference (參考文獻) 參考書目
     一、中文參考書目:
     了振豐(民76) 。學生場地獨立性與教學方法的交互作用對認知及情意學習效果之影響。師大輔導研究所碩士論文。
     王連生(民77) 。教育哲學研究。台北:五南圖書公司。
     中華技術院(民71) 。中文大辭典第四?。台北:文化大學出版部。
     孔令信(民72) 。巴斯卡:思考的蘆葦。台北:時報文化出版社。
     朱敬先(民77) 。教育心理學。台北:五南圖書社。
     江方盛(民79) 。高雄市國民小學教師批判思考教學行為之研究。師大碩士論文。
     李英明(民75) 。哈伯瑪斯。台北:東大圖書公司。
     李德高(民77) 。教育心理學。台北:五南圖書公司。
     倪鳴香(民70) 。幼兒創造力發展及其相關因素之研究。文化大學碩士論文。
     林玉體(民77) 。西洋教育史。台北:文景出版社。
     林清江(民69) 。我國中小學公民教育內涵及實施成效之研究。台北:行政院研考會。
     林清江(民70) 。教育社會學新論。台北:五南圖書公司。
     林瑞榮(民77) 。小學社會課程的發展趨勢及其啟示。師大碩士論文。
     韋政通(民73) 。中國哲學思想批判。台北:水牛出版社。
     柯華葳、秦葆琦(民75) 。中國見童政治行為研究。板橋:省國教教師研習會。
     唐華著(民70) 。中國理則學與西洋邏輯。台北:大中國圖書公司。
     許在世(民75) 。國民小學社會科教學現況及改進途徑之研究。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     張玉成(民78) 。教師發問技巧。台北:心理出版社。
     張守泰(民66) 。前導架構短文與認知型式對閱讀成績的影響。攻大教育研究所碩士論文。
     張春興，林清山(民75) 。教育心理學。台北:東華書局。
     張春典(民76) 。心理學概要。台北:東華書局。
     張春典(民78) 。張氏心理學辭典。台北:東華書局。
     郭生玉(民77) 。心理與教育測驗。台北:精華書局。
     黃公偉(民58) 。哲學概論。台北:帕米爾圖書公司。
     黃正鵠(民73) 。精神分析基本理論。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     溫世頌(民76) 。教育心理學。台北:三民書局。
     陳中人譯(民78) 。現象學與哲學的危機。台北:結構群出版社。
     陳曉林(民79) 。壯歲旌旗。台北:時報文化出版企業有限公司。
     陳伯璋(民76) 。潛在課程研究。台北:五南圖書公司。
     陳慶文(民59) 。學習心理學。台北:台灣書店。
     郭為藩(民76) 。科技時代的人文教育。台北:幼獅圖書公司。
     游恆山譯(民76) 。實用思考指南。台北:遠流出版社。
     項退結(民77) 。邁向未來的哲學思考。台北:東大圖書公司。
     程炳林(民80) 。國民中小學生激勵的學習策略之相關研究。政大碩士論文。
     楊莉容譯(民79) 。皮亞傑。台北:桂冠圖書公司。
     楊銀典(民76) 。國小學生場地獨立性、內外控信念與道德判斷的關係。師大教育研究所碩士論文。
     廖元輝譯(民77) 。思維心理學。台北:五洲出版社。
     編輯小組(民70) 。教育哲學。台北:文景出版社。
     劉伯明譯(民62) 。思維術。台北:華崗出版社。
     劉德勝(民76) 。小學社會科課程結構與內涵。高雄:復文圖書公司
     齊隆鯤(民76) 。諮商投術與策略。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     歐用生、林瑞欽(民75) 。價值澄清法。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     歐用生(民78) 。課程與教學--概念、理論與實際。台北:文景出版社。
     歐陽教(民71) 。道德判斷與道德教學。台北:文景出版社。
     鍾聖校(民79) 。認知心理學。台北:心理出版社。
     葉學志(民73) 。教育哲學。台北:三民書局。
     籃順德(民75) 。公民教育的內涵。高雄:復文圖書公司。
     二、中文參考期刊:
     毛連溫、劉燦梁、陳麗華(民80) 。康乃爾批判思考測驗之修訂。
     中國測驗學會測驗年刊，第38輯，頁109-123 。
     江芳盛(民78) 。為甚麼要教導學生思考。現代教育，第四卷，第四期，頁145-153 。
     成中英(民72) 。啟盟運動中理性角色的反省與自覺。中國論壇，第十六卷，第三期，頁7-8 。
     吳靜吉等(民68) 。場地獨立性的發展及其相關因素之研究。教育與心理研究，第三期，頁118-139 。
     吳靜吉(民79) 0 未發表之講義。
     林玉體(民76) 。談邏輯解析與思考教學。現代教育，第二卷，第三期，頁63-70 。
     柯麗儀、周麗玉(民78) 。躍吉斯與你--真誠、尊重與同理的暸解。
     諮商與輔導，第39期，頁45-46。
     胡夢鯨(民77) 。從思想研究的本質與步驟談「回歸原典」的必要性。現代教育，第三卷，第二期，頁150-161 。
     高廣孚(民76) 。哲學分析與教學研究。現代教育，第二卷，第二期，頁43-62 。
     陳伯璋(民79) 。哈伯瑪斯「批判解釋學」及其對課程研究的啟示。
     師大教育研究所集刊，第24輯，頁73-131 。
     陳麗華(民78) 。國小社會科批判思考教學的省思。現代教育，第七卷，第15期，頁121-135 。
     張春興(民77) 。知之歷程與教之歷程:認知心理學的發展及其在教育上的應用。教育心理學報，第21期，頁17-18 。
     歐陽教(民53) 。康德的哲學與教育思想。師大教研所集刊，第七集，頁242 。
     歐陽教(民76) 。教學的哲學分析。現代教育，第二卷，第二期，頁32-41 。
     蘇永明(民69) 。杜威的教育哲學。今日教育，第38期，頁69-73。
     三、英文參考書目
     Baron, J., Badgio, P. C. & Gaskins, I. W. (1986). Cognitive
     styles and its improvement: a normative approach. In R. J.
     Sternberg (ed.) Advances In the psychology of human
     intelligence. Broadway: Lawrence Erlbaum Association, Inc.
     Baron, J. B. & Sternberg, R. J. (1986). Teaching thinking
     skills: theory and practice. New York: W. H. Freeman
     Company.
     Bastein, C. (1985). A developmental model of problem solving.
     In G`ery d`YDEWALLE (ed.) Cognition. information
     processing. and motivation. Emsterdam: Elsevier Science
     Publishing Company.
     Beck, R. C . (1983) . Motivation: theories and principles..
     Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall. Inc.
     Beyer, B. K. (1988b). Developing a thinking skills program.
     Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Inc.
     Borkowski. J. G. & Krause. A. J. (1985). Metacognition and
     attributional beliefs. In G`ery d`YDEWALLE (ed.) Cognjtion.
     information processing. and motivation. Emsterdam: Elsevier
     Science Pulishing Company.
     Brookfield. S. D. (1987). Developing critical thinkers:
     challenge adults to explore alternative ways of thinking
     actjng. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
     Connerton. P. (1978). Critical sociology. Harmondsworth:
     Penguin Press.
     Dewey. J. (1910). How we think. Boston: Heath.
     Ennis. R. H. (1985b). Goals for a critical thinking
     curriculum. In A. L. Costa (ed.) Developing minds: a
     resource book for teaching Thinking. Virginia: ASCD.
     
     Ennis. R. H., Millman, J. & Tomko, T . N . (1985) . Cornell
     critical thinking tests level X & level Z-Manual. CA:
     Midwest Publications.
     Ennis, R. H. (1987). A taxonomy of critical thinking
     dispositions and abilities. In J. B. Baron & R. J. Sternberg
     (eds.) Teaching thinking skills: theory and practice. New
     York: W. H. Freeman Company.
     Evans. J. St B.T. (1983). Thinking and reasoning. London:
     Routledge & Kegan Paul.
     Freeman, W. H. (1986). Teaching thinking skills: theory and
     practice. In J. B. Baron & R. J. Sternberg (eds.) Teaching
     thinking skills: Theory and practice. New York: W. H.
     Freeman Company.
     Goldstein, K. M. & Blackman, S. (1978). Cognitive style.
     Ohio: John Wiley & Son. Inc.
     Grant. G. E. (1988). Teaching critical thinking. New York:
     Praeger Publishers.
     Hoffman, M. L. (1986). Affect-cognition and motivation. In
     R. M. Sorrentino & E. T. Huggins (eds.) Handbook of
     motivation and cognition. New York: Guilford Publication.
     Hudgins. B. B. (1977). Learning & teaching-a prImer for
     teachers. Illinois: F. E. Peacock Publishers, Inc.
     Kuhl, J. & Wassijew, I. (1985). An information processing
     perspective on motivation: intrinsic task-involvement,
     problem solving, and the complexity of action plans. In
     G`ery d`YDEWALLE (ed. ) Cognition. information processing.
     and motivation. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishing
     Company.
     Kuhl. J & Atkinson. J. W. (1986). Motivation. thought. and
     action. New York: Praeger Publishers.
     Kuhl. J. & Geiger. E. (1986). The dynamic theory of the
     anxiety allocation. In J. kuhl & J. W. Atkinson (eds.)
     Motivatjon. TbOUght. and Action. New York : Praeger
     Publishers. New York: Praeger Publishers.
     Kuhl. J. & Blankenship. (1989). The dynamic theory of
     achievement motovation: from episodic to dynamic thinking.
     In J. Kuhl & J. `W. Atkinson (eds. ) Motivation. thought.
     and action. New York: Praeger Publishers.
     Kuhl. J. (1986). Motivation and information processing: a
     new look at decision making, dynamic change, and action
     Control. In R. M. Sorrentino & E. T. Higgins (eds.)
     Handook of motivation and cognition. New York: Guilford
     Publication.
     Mayer. R. E. (1987). educational psychology: a cognitive
     approach. Boston: Little. Brown and Company.
     Mckeachie. `W. J .? Pintrich. P. R. & Lin. Y. (1985). Learn to
     learn. In G`ery d`YOEWALLE (ed.) Cognition. information
     processing. and motivation. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science
     Publishing Company.
     Mctighe, J. & Schollonberger. J. (1985). Why teach thinking:
     a statement of rationale. In A. L. Costa (eds.)
     Developing Minds. U. S. : The Association for Supervision &
     Curriculum Development.
     Neimark. E. D. (1987). Advantures In thinking. Orlando:
     Harcourt `Brace Jovanovich. Inc.
     Nickerson. R. S .. Perkins. D. N .. & Smith. E. E. (1985). The
     teaching of thinking. Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum
     Associates. Publishers.
     Nickerson, R. S. (1986). Reasoning. In R. F. Dillion & R. J.
     Sternberg (eds.) Cognition and instruction. California:
     Academic Press, Inc.
     Norris, S. P. & and Ennis R. H. (1989). Evaluating critical
     thinking. C. A. : Midwest Publications.
     Ozman, H. A.& Craver, S. M. (1986). Philosophical
     foundations of education. Columbus: A Brell &Howell
     Paul. R. (1990b). Critical thinking: What every person needs
     to survive in a rapidly changing world. C.A.: Center for
     Critical Thinking and Morale Critique.
     Pintrich, P. R. (1988). A process-oriented View or student
     motivation and cognition. In J. S. Stark & L. Mets (eds.)
     Improving teaching and learning through research. San
     Francisco: Jessy-Bass.
     Pintrich. P. R. (1989). The dynamic interplay of student
     motivation and cognition in the college classroom. In C.
     Ames & M. Machr (eds.) Advences In motivation and
     achievement. Grinwich: TAI Press.
     Pressisen. B. Z.(1985). Thinking skills: meaning and models.
     In Costa. A. L.(ed.) Developing minds: a resource book
     for teaching thinking. Virginia: ASCD.
     Raynor, J. O. & Mcfarlin, (1986). Motivation and the Self-system.
     In R. M. Sorrentino(ed.) Handbook of motivation
     and Cognition. New York: Guilford Publication.
     Ruggiero, V. R. (1988). Teaching thinking across the
     curriculum. New York: Happer & Row Publishers.
     Scheffler, I. (1973). Reason and teaching. London: Routhedge
     and Kagan Paul .
     Siegel, H. (1988). Educating reason: rationality, critical
     thinking and education. London: Roulthedge.
     Siegler, R. S. (1986). Children`s thinking. Englewood Cliffs:
     Prentice-Hall. Inc.
     Smith, R. M. (1982). Learning how to learn. Cambridge: The
     Adult Education Company.
     Sternberg. R. (1985a). Critical thinking: its nature,
     measurement, and improvement. In R. L. Frances (ed.)
     Essays on the Intellect. Virginia: ASCD.
     Sternbeg, R. (1986). Cognition and instruction: why the
     marriage sometimes ends in divorce. In R. F. Dillion & R.
     J. Sternberg (eds.) Cognition and instruction. California:
     Academic Press. Inc.
     Witkin, H. A. (1978). Cognitive styles in personal cultural
     adapt ion. Clark University Press.
     Yinger. R. J. (1980). Can We really teach them to think? In
     R. E. Young (ed.) Eorstering critical thinking. San
     Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
     Young, R. E. (1980). Editor`s notes: critical thinking--a
     renewed interest. In R. E. Young (ed.) Forstering Critical
     Thinking. San Fracisco: Jossey-Bass.
     四、英文參考期刊：
     Alexander, P. A., Willson, V. L., White, C. S. & Fuqua, J. D.
     (1987). Analogical reasoning in young children. Journal of
     Educational Psychology. 79(4). 401-408.
     Annis, L. F. (1979). Effect of cognitive style and learning
     passage organization on study technique effectiveness.
     Journal of Educational Psychology, 71(5). 620-626.
     Arnold G. H. Hart, A. & Campbell. K. (1988). Introducing the
     Wednesday revolution. Educatjonal Leadership, 45(7), 48.
     Barell, J., Liebmann. R. & Sigel, I. (1988).Forstering
     thoughtful self-direction in students, Educational
     Leardership. 45(7), 14-17.
     Baxter, M. & Marcia, B. (1987).Gender differences in
     cognitive development. Paper presented at the Annual
     Meeting of the American Educational Research Association
     Washington.DC .
     Batcheller, M F. (1985). Implementing a critical thinking
     skills program in the social studies curriculum K-12
     Educational leadership, 42(8), 46.
     Beyer, B. K. (1983) . Commen sense about teaching thinking
     skills. Educational Leadership. 41(3), 44-49.
     Beyer, B. K. (1985a). Critical thinking: What is it? Social
     Education, 49(4), 270-276.
     Beyer, B. K. (1985b). Teaching critical thinking: a direct
     approach. Social Education. 49(4), 297-303.
     Beyer, B. K. (1985c). Critical thinking revisited. Social
     Education, 49(4), 268-269.
     Beyer, B. K. (1988a). Developing a scope and sequence for
     skills instruction. Educational Leadershjp, 45(7), 26-30.
     Biggs, J. B. (1978). Individual and group differences in
     study processes. British Journal of Educational Psychology,
     4a(3). 266-279.
     Bitner. C & Betty, L. (1988) . Logical and critical
     thinking abilities of sixth through twelfth grade students
     and formal reasonlng modes as predictors of critical
     thinking abilities and academic achievement. Paper
     presented at the Annual Meeting of the National
     Association for Research in `Science Teaching. Lake of the
     Ozarks, MO.
     Brandt. R. S. (1985). On creativity and thinking skills: a
     coversation with David Perkins. Educational Leadership, 43
     (4). 12-13.
     Brell. C. D. (1990). Critical- thinking . as transfer: the
     reconstructive integration of otherwise discrete
     interpretations of experience. Educational Theory, 40(1),
     53-85.
     Brown. L.E .. & Cook, E. (1975). How children`s interests
     affect their critical thinking ability. Educational
     Leadership. 32(5). 339-342.
     Bussey, K. & Maughan, B. (1982). Gender difference in
     reasoning. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
     42(4). 701-706.
     Derrico, P. J. (1988). Learning to think with philosophy for
     children. Educational Leadership, 45(7), 34.
     Diamond. I. D. (1977). Resistence to change: relationship of
     personality and cognitive innovation diffusion process.
     Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the College
     Reading Association. Cincinati, Ohi.
     Doherty, D. C. (1990). Using corporate-sponsored materials
     to teach history and social science skills. Educational
     Leadership, 47(4). 81-83.
     Doolittle, A. & Welch. C. (1989). Gender differences in
     performance on the college-level achievement test. Paper
     presented at the Annual Meeting of the American
     Educational Research Association. San Fracisco, CA.
     Doyle, W. & Cater, K. (1984). Academic tasks In classroom.
     Curricylum Inquiry, 14(2), 139-149.
     Dunkin, M. J. & Doenau, S. J,. (1980). A replication study
     of unique and Joint contributions to variance In student
     achievement. 72(3). 394-403.
     Echeverria, E. (1990). Learning and using critical thinking.
     Unpublished paper in Philosophy for Children: East and
     West, 1-13.
     Ehri, L. C. & Muzio. I. M. (1974). Cognitive style and
     reasoning about speed. Journal of Educational Psychology,
     66,569-571.
     Ennis. R. H. (1962). A concept of critical thinking. Harvard
     Educatjoal Review, 32(1), 81-111.
     Ennis. R. H. (1985a). A logical basis for measuring critical
     thinking skills. Educational Leadershjp, 43(2), 45-48.
     Ennis, R. H. (1985c). Critical thinking and the curriculum.
     Phi Kappa Phi Journal. 65(1), 28-31.
     Farrar, M. T. (1986). Four conceptions of literacy. Reading
     Psychology, 7(1). 43-55.
     Flexer. B. K. & Roberge, J. J. (1983). A longitudinal
     investigation of field dependence-independence and the
     development of formal operatinal thought. British Journal
     of Educational Psychology, 53(part 2) 195-204.
     Frank. B. M. (1984). Effect of independence-dependence and
     study technique on learning from a lecture. American
     Educational Research. 3(21), 669-678.
     Fridman, G. H .. Lehrer, B. E. & Stevens. J. P. (1983). the
     effectiveness of self-directed and lecture/ discussion
     stresss management approaches and the locus of control of
     teacher. American Educational Research Journal, 20(4), 563-
     580.
     Garett. K., & Wulf, K. (1978). The relationship of a measure
     of critical thinking ability to personality variables and
     to indicators of academic achievement. Educational and
     Psychological Measurement, 38(4), 1181-1187.
     Gibbs, J. C. et ale (1986) . Relations between moral
     judgement. moral courage. and field independence. Child
     Development. 57(1). 185-193
     Hansson, S. B .. Ryden. D. D., & Johnsson. P. (1986). field-dependence/
     independence: ability in relation to mobility-fixity.
     Perceptual and Motor Skills. 63(1. part1). 279-293.
     Hawly, W. D. (1988). Missing pieces of the educational
     reform agenda: or. why the first and second waves may miss
     the boat. Educational Administration Quarterly. 24(4). 416-
     437.
     Hertzberg, H. (1988). Foundations. Social Education. 52(2).
     144-145.
     --- 193 "-`
     Hoogstraten, J .. & Christiaans. H. H. C. M. (1975). The
     relationship of the watson-glaser critical` thinking
     appraisal to sex and four selected personality measures
     for a sample of Dutch first-year psychology students.
     Educatjonal and Psychological Measurement, 35(4). 969-973.
     Hudgins. B. B.,& Edelman. S. (1986) . Teaching critical
     skills to fourth and fifth grades through critical teacher-lead
     small-group disscussions. Journal of Educational?
     Research. 79(6). 333-342.
     Hudgins. B. B.. & Edelman. S. (1988). Children `s self-directed
     critical thinking. The Journal of Educational
     Research.81(5). 262-273.
     Hudgins. B. B .? Riesenmy. M, Ebel, D. & Edelman. S. (1989) .
     Children`s critical thinking: a model for its analysis and
     two examples. Educational Research. 82(6). 327-338.
     Hurov. J. T. (1987). A study of the relationship between
     reading. computational. and critical thinking skills and
     academic success in fundamental of chemistry. Research
     report.
     Johnson, D. W. & Johnson. R. T. (1987). Research shows the
     benefits of adult cooperation. Educational Leadership. 45
     (3). 27-30.
     Kagan. S. & Zahn. G. L. (1982). Generalized maternal
     reinforcement and children`s reading achievement. math
     achievement and field independence. The Journal of Genetic
     Psychology. 141. 93-104.
     Knight. S. L .. Waxman. H. C. And Padron. Y. N. (1989) .
     Students` perceptions of relationships between social
     studies instruction and cognitive strategies. Educational
     Research. 82(5). 270-276.
     Kownslar, A. O. (1985). What`s worth having students think
     critical about? Social Education, 49(4), 304-307.
     Kulleseid, E. R. (1986). Extending the research base: schema
     theory, cognitive styles, and types of intelligence. School
     Library Media Quartlv, 15(1), 41-48.
     Lundeberg, M. A. & Fox, P. W. (1991) . Do laboratory
     findings on test _expectancy generalize to classroom
     outcomes? Review of Educational Research. 62(1), 94-106.
     McCamon, S. et al. (1988). Predicting course performance In
     freshman and sophomore physics courses: women are more
     predictabIe the men. Journal od Research in Science
     Teaching, 25(6), 501-510.
     Manning, B. H., & Payne, B. D. (1989). A cognitive self-direction
     model for teacher education. Journal of Teacher
     Education, 4Q(3) , 27-32.
     McCammon, S et al. (1988). Predicting course performance In
     freshman and sophomore physics courses: women are more
     predictable than men. Journal of Research in Science
     Teaching, 25(6), 501-510.
     McDonald, E. R. (1984). The relationship of student and
     faculty field dependence/independence congruence to
     student academic achievement. Educational and Psychological
     Measurement, 44, 725-731.
     McFarland. M . A. (1985). Critical thinking in elementary
     school social studies. Social Educatjon, 49(4). 277-280.
     McMillan. J. H. (1987). Enhancing college students` critical
     thinking: a review of studies. Research in Higher Education.
     26(1), 3-19.
     McPeck, J. E. (1984). Stalking beasts. but swatting flies:
     the teaching of critical thinking. Canadian Journal of
     Education, 9(1), 28-44.
     Michalak. S. J. (1986). Enhancing critical thinking skills
     in traditional liberal arts courses: report on a faculty
     workshop. Liberal Education, 72(3), 253-261.
     Mirrnan, J. & Tiahman S. (1988). Infusing thinking through
     connections". Educational Leadership, 4:5(7), 64-65.
     Nenitto, J. & Strickland, J. (1987). Critical thinking: a
     skill for all seasons. College Student Journal, 21(2), 201-
     204.
     Newton, B. T. (1978). Theoretical bases for higher cognitive
     questioning-an avenue to critical thinking. Education, 98
     (3), 286-291.
     Niaz. M. & Lawson, A. E. (1985) . Balancing chemical
     equations: the role of developmental level and mental
     capacity. Journal of Research in Science Teaching,22(1),
     41-51.
     Niaz,M. (1987) .Mobility-flexity dimension in Witkin’s
     theory of field-dependence/ independence and its
     Motor: Skills. 65(3),755-764.
     Niaz, M. (1989). The role of cognitive style and its
     influence on proportional reasoning. Perceptual and Motor
     Skills, 26(3). 221-235.
     Norris, S. P. (1985). Synthesis of research on critical
     thinking. Educational Leadership, 42(8), 40-45.
     Norris, S. P., & Phillips, L. M. (1987) . Explanations of
     reading comprehension: schema theory and critical thinking
     theory. Teachers College Record, 89(2). 281-306.
     Norris. S. P. (1988). Research needed on critical thinking.
     Canadjan Journal of Education. 13(1). 125-137.
     Overton. W. , Byrnes. J. P ., & O`brien, D. P. (1985).
     Developmental and individual differences In conditional
     reasoning: the role of contradition training and cognitive
     style. Developmental Psychology, 21(4). 692-701.
     Paradise. L. V & Block. C. (1984). The relationship of
     teacher-student cognitive style to academic achievement.
     Journal of Research and Development and Education. 17(4),
     57-61.
     Paul. R. H. (1984). Critical thinking: fundamental to
     education for a free society. Educational Leadership, 42
     (1). 4-14.
     Pau 1. R. W. (1985). Bloom`s Taxonomy and critical
     instruction. Educational Leadership. 42(8). 36-39.
     Paul. R. W. & Adamson. K. R. (1990). Critical thinking and
     the nature of prejudice. Paper presented at The 10th
     Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking and
     Educational Reform, 1-48.
     Pierce, W., Lemke. E., & Smith. R. (1988). Critical thinking
     and moral development in secondary students. The High
     School Journal. 71(3). 120-126.
     Pintrich, P. R. (1986). Motivation and learning strategies
     interactions with achievement. Paper presented at the
     American Educational Reserch Association Convention. San
     Francisco. California. 1-19.
     Pintrich, P. R. (1987). Motivated learning strategies in the
     college classroom. Paper presented at the American
     Educational Research Association Convention, Washington,D.
     C. 1-38.
     Pogrow, S. (1988). Teaching thinking to at-risk elementary
     students. Educational Leadership, 45(7), 79-85.
     Roach, D. A. (1985). Effects of cognitive style,
     intelligence, and sex on reading achievement. Perceptual
     And Motor Skills, 51(3, part 2),1139-1142.
     Rornanish, B. (1986). Critical thinking and the curriculum: a
     critique. The Educational Forum, 51(1), 45-55.
     Ronning, R.R., Mccurdy, D. & Ballinger, R. (1984).
     Individual defferences: a third component in problem-solving
     instruction. Journal of Research in Science
     Teaching, 21(1), 71-82.
     Sadler, W. A., & Whimbey, A. (1985). A holistic approach to
     improving thinking skills. Phi Delta Kappan, 67(2),199-203.
     Saracho, O. N. & Dayton, C. M. (1980). Relationship of
     teachers` cognitive styles to pupils` academic achievement
     gains. Journal of Educational Psychology, 72(4), 544-549.
     Sasseville, M. (1990). Chapter one of Harry Stottlemeier’s
     discovery: a cl:ucible integratol: of critical and creative
     thinking. Paper presented at the Philosophy for Children
     East and West, 1-5.
     Shelly, A. C. & Willam, W. W. (1988). Sex equity and critical
     thinking. Social Education, 52(3), 168-173.
     Shulk, J. P. (1987). Knowledge and teaching: foundations of
     the new reform. Harvard Educational Review, 57(1), 1-22.
     Shulk. J. P. (1988). Project IMPACT in elementary school.
     Educational Leadership, 45(7), 41.
     Siegel, H. (1980). Critical thinking as an educational
     ideal. The Educational Forum, 45(1), 7-23.
     Smith. D. G. (1977) . College classroom Interactions and
     critical thinking. Journal of Educational Psychology, 69
     (2). 180-190.
     Solomon, S. J. & Wurster. S. R. (1978). Correlations between
     critical thinking achievement and scholastic aptitude In
     high school seniors. Research report.
     Sternberg. R. J. (1984) . How can we teach intelligence?
     Educatjonal Leadership, 42(1), 38-50.
     Sternberg, R. J. (1985a) . A statewide approach to
     measuring critical thinking skills. Educational Leadership,
     43(2), 40-43.
     Sternberg, R. J. (1985b). Teaching critical thinking, part 1:
     are we making critical mistakes? Phi Delta Kappan. 67(3),
     194-198.
     Sternberg, R. J. (1985c). Teaching criticl thinking. part 2:
     possible solutions. Phi Delta Kappan, 67(4), 277-280.
     Steward. R. J. & AI-Abdulla. Y. (1989). An examination of
     the relationship between critical thinking and academic
     success on a university campus. Research report.
     Tabor. M. (1988). Better student thinking through changing
     teacher behaviors. Educational Leadership, 45.(7), 49-51.
     Thomas, C. R. (1983a). Field independence and myers-briggs
     thinking individuals. Perceptual and Motor Skills. 57(3.
     part 1), 790.
     Thomas, C. R . (1983b). Fie 1 d independence and technical
     achivement. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 57(3, part 1). 858.
     WaIsh, D. (1988). Critical thinking to reduce prejudice.
     Social Education, 52(4), 280-282.
     Walters, K. S. (1986) . Critical thinking in liberal
     education: a case of overkill ? Liberal Education, 72(3),
     233-244.
     Walters, k. S. (1989) . Critical thinking in teacher
     education: towards a demythologization. Journal of Teacher
     Education, 40(3) , 14-19.
     Welkowitz, L. A., & Calkins, R. p. (1984) . Effects of
     cognitive and exemplar modeling on field depencdnce-independence.
     Perceptual and Motor Skills, 58(2, part 2),
     439-442.
     WiIIams, B. (1987). Implementing thinking skills instruction
     in an uban district: an effect to close the gap. Educational
     Leadership, 44(6), 50-53.
     White, C. S. & Fuqua, J. D. (1987). Analogical reasoning in
     young children .. Journal of Educational Psychology, 79(4).
     401-408.
     Witkin, H. A. & Goodenough, D. R. (1977). Field-dependent
     and field-independent cognitive styles. Review of
     Educational Research, 47(1), 1-64.
     Witkin, H. A. et al. (1977) . Field-dependent and Field-independent
     cognitive styles and their educational
     implications. Review of Educational Research. 47(1), 1-64.
     Wolfle, L. M. & Robertshaw, D. (1982) . Effects of college
     attendence on locus of control. Journal od Personality and
     Social psychology, 43(4), 802-810.
     Worsham. A. W. & Austin, G. R. (1984). Effects of teaching
     Thinking skills on SAT scores, 41(3), 50-51.
     Zenke. L. & Alexander, L. (1984). Teaching thinking in Tulsa.
     Educational Leadershjp. 42(1), 81-84.		zh_TW