1. NCCU Academic Hub
  2. Publications
  3. College of International Affairs
  4. Theses
  5. Item

Publications-Theses

Article View/Open

Publication Export

Google ScholarTM

NCCU Library

Citation Infomation

Related Publications in TAIR

題名 階級理論的兩大傳統-馬克思與韋伯階級概念的比較
作者 詹政道
貢獻者 顧忠華
詹政道
日期 1990
1989
上傳時間 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8)
參考文獻 參考書目
一、中文部分:
1.王振寰
1980 「韋伯『理性化』的意義及其對工具理性的批評」，思與言，18卷4期，(11):289~306。
2.王章陵
1982 「馬克思的歷史階段一一從資本主義社會到共產主義社會(二)」，共黨問題研究，8卷9期，(9):1~13。
3.布洛克曼
1987 結構主義，台北:谷風出版社。
4.列寧
1945 國家與革命，北平:解放社。
5.何忠良
1988 「青年馬克思意識型態觀的探索」，東亞季刊，19卷3期，(1):35~53。
6.李青宜
1988 阿爾杜塞爾與結構主義馬克思主義，台北:谷風出版社。
7.沈起予
1982 「馬克思的人學」，中國大陸月刊，178期，(6):52~59。
8.金子榮一
1986 韋伯的比較社會學，台北:水牛出版社。
9.周伯戡譯著
1986 社會思想的冠冕:韋伯，台北:時報出版公司。
10.帕爾金(Frank Parkin) 黃丘隆譯
1989 馬克斯﹒韋伯，台北:結構出版群。
11.馬克思
1961 路易波拿巴的霧月十八日，「馬克思恩格斯全集」(以下簡稱「馬恩全集」)第8卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965a 共產黨宣言，馬恩全集第4卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965b 哲學的貧困，馬恩全集第4卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965c 德意志意識型態，馬恩全集第3卷，北平;人民出版社。
1965d 法蘭西內戰，馬恩全集第17卷，北平;人民出版社。
1965e 哥達綱領批判，馬恩全集第19卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965f 政治經濟學批判序言，馬恩全集第13卷，北平:人民出版社。
1974 資本論第三卷，馬恩全集第25卷，北平:人民出版社。
1979 一八四四年經濟學哲學手稿，馬恩全集第42卷，北平:人民出版社。
12契波拉編
1984 歐洲經濟史(工業革命篇)II，張彬村編譯，台北:允晨文化公司。
1985 歐洲經濟史:工業社會的興起I，張彬村、林灑華譯，台北:允晨文化公司。
13.柯塞 黃瑞祺、張維安譯
1988 古典社會學理論，台北:桂冠圖書公司。
14.施路赫特(Wolfgang Schluchter) 顧忠華譯
1986 理性化與官僚化一一對韋伯的研究與詮釋，台北:聯經出版公司。
15.胡麗玲
1985 馬克思主義階級論之研究，政治大學東亞研究所碩士論文。
16.韋伯(Max Weber)
1985a 支配的類型，康樂編譯，台北:遠流出版社。
1985b 學術與政治，錢永祥編譯，台北:遠流出版社。
17.高承恕
1988 理性化與資本主義一一韋伯與韋伯之外，台北:聯經出版社。
18.徐崇溫
1985 西方馬克思主義，台北:谷風出版社。
19.陳介玄、翟本瑞、張維安
1989 韋伯論西方社會的理性化，台北:巨流圖書公司。
20.許津橋
1987 社會理論與政治實踐，台北:圓神出版社。
21.畢浩明編
1987 社會學:界限與侷限，台北:谷風出版社。
22.黃瑞祺
1980 「韋伯的弔詭」，思與言，18卷4期，(11):307~327。
23.許嘉猷
1986 社會階層化與社會流動，台北:三民書局。
24.張潤書
1976 行政學，台北:三民書局。
25.張一柱譯
1986 「共黨在西歐:沈滯不前的政黨」，中國大陸研究教學參考資料，39期，(3):86。
26.張華葆
1987 社會階層，台北:三民書局。
27.樊亢主編
1985 資本主義興衰史，北平:北京出版社。
28.Kautsky, k.(考茨基)
1980 論無產階級專政，台北:黎明文化公司。
29.Mantoux, P.周寰文譯
1976 十八世紀的產業革命，台北:中華書局。
30.Ritzer,G.馬康莊、陳信木譯
1989 社會學理論，台北:巨流圖書公司。

二、英文部分
1. Balbus, I. D .
1982 Marxism and Domination, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
2. Beetham, D.
1985 Max Weber and Theory of Modern Politics,Cambridge: Polity Press.
3. Bologh, R.W.
1984 "Max Weber and the Di1emma of Rationality" in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London : Greenwood Press. PP. 175~186.
4. Bottomore, T. ed.
1983 A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, Cambridge (U.S.A) : Harvard University Press.
5. Castoriadis, C.
1980 "Socialism and Autonomous Society," TELOS No. 43. ( spring) : 91~105 .
6. Connel, R. W.
1980 " A Critique of the Althusserian Approach to Class," Theory and Society vol. 8. No . 3.(11): 303~345.
7. Crompton, R.
1976 "Approaches to the Study of White-Collar Unionism," Sociology vo1. 10. No.3. (9) :
407~426.
8. Dow Jur, T. E.
1978 "An Analysis of Weber`s Work on Charisma,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1.(3): 83~93.
9. Eisen, A.
1978 "The Meanings & Confusions of Weberians` Rationality," British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1. (3): 57~70.
10. Form, W.
1973 "The Internal Stratification of the Working Class:System Involvement of Auto Workers in Four Countries," American Sociological Review vo1. 38. No.4. (12) : 697~711.
1983 “Sociological Research and American Working Class," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 24.NO.2. (Spring) : 163~184.
11. Giddens, A.
1981 Politics and Sociology in the Thought of Max Weber, London: The Macmillan Press LTD.
12 Girardin, Jean-Claude
1974 "On the Marxist Theory of the state," Politics and Society vo1. 4. NO.2. PP.193~223.
13. Goldman, R. & Tickamyer. A.
1984 “Status Attainment and the Commodity Form:Stratification in Historical Perspective,"American Sociologica1 Review vo1. 49. (4) : 196~209.
14. Gray, R. Q.
1975 “ Critical Note: The Political Incorporation of the Working Class," Sociology vo1. 19. No. 1. (1): 101 ~ 104.
15. Jacoby, R.
1978 “Political Economy and Class Consciousness," Theory and Society vo1. 5 . No.1. (1): 11~18.
16.Jensen-Bulter, B.
1976 “An Outline of a Weberian Analysis of Class With Particular Reference to the Middle Class and the NSDAP in Weimar Germany,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 27. No.1 .(3): 50 ~ 60.
17. King, L. & Child, J. & Pearce, S.
1980 "Class Perspections and Social Identification of Industrial Supervisors," Sociology
vol. 14. No.3. (8): 563 ~599.
18. Levine, R.F. & Lembcke, J. ed.
1987 Recapturing Marxism: An Appraisa1 of Recent Trends in Sociological Theory, New York:Praeger Publishers.
19. Lopreato, J. & Hazelrigg, L.E.
1972 Class, Conflict, and Mobility, San Francisco:Chandler Publishing Co.
20. Miliband, R .
1978 Marxism and Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
21. McLoughlin, I.
1982 "Misunderstanding the New Middle Class,"Sociology vol. 16. No.4. (11): 586~590.
22. Mommsen, Wolfgang J.
1985 “Capitalism and Socialism: Weber`s Dialogue With Marx," in A Weber-Marx Dialogue, ed. by R. J. Antonio & R.M. Glassman,台北:原學出版社。PP. 234~256.
23. Murphy, R.
1984 “The Structure of Closure: A Critique and Development of the Theories of Weber, Collins,and Parkin," British Journal of Sociology vol 35. No .4. (12): 547~567.
1986 "Weberian Closure Theory:A Contribution to the Ongoing Assessment," British Journal of Sociology vol. 37. NO.1. (3): 21~41.
24. Murvar, V.
1984 “Epilogue: Max Weber and the Two Nonrevolut-ionry Events in Russia 1917: Scientific Achievement or Prophetic Failures? ,"in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R. M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London: Greenwood Press. PP.237~272.
25. Ollman, B.
1972 “Towards Class Consciousness Next Time: Marx and The Working Class," Politics and Society vol. 3. No. 1. (Fall) : 1~24.
26. Parkin, F.
1982 “Social Closure and Class Formation," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed. by A. Giddens and D. Held, California : California University.PP.175~184.
27. Przeworski, A.
1977 "Proletariat into a Class: The Process of Class Formation from Karl Kautsky`s The
Class Struggle to Recent Controversies,"Politics and Society vol. 7. No. 4. PP. 343~401.
28. Robinson, R.V. & Kelley, J.
1979 “Class as Conceived by Marx & Dahrendorf :Effects On Income Inequality and Politics in the United States & Great Britain," American Sociological Review vol. 44. No.1. (2) : 38~57 .
29. Scruton, R.
1985 Thinkers of the New Left, 台北:唐山出版社。
30. Swatos, W.H.
1984 "Revolution and Charisma in a Rationalized World: Weber Revisited and Extend," in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London :Greenwood Press.PP.201~215.
31 Tanner, J. & Cockerrill, R.
1986 "In Search of Working-Class Ideology: A Test of Two Perspectives," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 27. No.3. (9) : 389~402.
32 Taylor, S.
1978 “Parkin`s Theory of Working Class Conservation: Two Hypotheses Investigated," The Sociological Review vol. 26. No.4. (11): 827~842.
33 Tones, Bryn
1975 "Max Weber and The Concept of Social Class," The Sociological Review vol. 23. NO.4. (11) :729~759.
34 Va11as, S.
1987 "White-Collar Proletarians ?The structure of Clerical Work and Levels of Class Consciousness,"The Sociological Quarterly vol. 28. NO.4. (12): 523~540.
35 Weber, M.
1978 Weber: Selections in Translation, tran. By E. Matthews, ed . by W.G. Runciman, London:Cambridge University Press.
1982 "Selections from Economy and Society vol. 1 & vo1. 2. & Genera1 Economy History," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed . by A. Giddens & D. Held,California:California University.PP. 60~86.
1985 Economy and Society, 台北:宗青圖書公司。
36 Wenger, M. G .
1987 .. Class Closure and The Historical/ Structure Limits of Marx-Weber Convergence," in The Marx-Weber Debate ed. by N. Wiley, California:SAGE Publications LTD.PP.43~64.
37 Wiley, N. ed.
1987 The Marx-Weber Debate, London: SAGE Publications LTD.
38 Wright, E.O.
1976 "Class Boundaries in Advanced Capitalist Societies," New Left Review No. 98. (6): 3~41.
1980 “Varieties of Marxist Conceptions of Class Structure, " Po1itics and Society vol. 9. No. 3. PP. 323~370.
39 Zussman, R .
1984 “The Middle Levels: Engineers and the Working Middle Class," Politics and Society vol. 13 . No.3. PP. 217~237.
描述 碩士
國立政治大學
東亞研究所
資料來源 http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#B2002005281
資料類型 thesis
dc.contributor.advisor 顧忠華zh_TW
dc.contributor.author (Authors) 詹政道zh_TW
dc.creator (作者) 詹政道zh_TW
dc.date (日期) 1990en_US
dc.date (日期) 1989en_US
dc.date.accessioned 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.available 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.issued (上傳時間) 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8)-
dc.identifier (Other Identifiers) B2002005281en_US
dc.identifier.uri (URI) http://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/90336-
dc.description (描述) 碩士zh_TW
dc.description (描述) 國立政治大學zh_TW
dc.description (描述) 東亞研究所zh_TW
dc.description.tableofcontents 目錄
第一章導論…………1
第一節階級的語源…………1
第二節資本主義經濟結構的變遷…………3
第二章馬克思的階級概念…………7
第一節社會的階級分析…………7
(一)階級劃分的標準與「中間階級」…………7
(二)經理階級…………15
第二節宰制的面向…………16
(一)結構性的宰制…………17
1.經濟結構的宰制…………17
2.法律、政治結構的宰制…………18
(二)意識型態的宰制…………23
第三節異化狀態的自覺與階級鬥爭…………24
(一)鬥爭與階級意識…………24
(二)階級意識發展的客觀條件…………30
第四節階級的消滅…………33
(一)第一階段…………34
(二)最高階段…………38
第三章韋伯的階級概念…………45
第一節社會行動與市場…………45
(一)社會行動…………45
(二)市場…………47
第二節階級…………48
第三節社會壁壘(social exclusion)——階級、地位團體、政黨的關係…………55
(一)地位團體及其與階級的關係…………57
(二)階級、地位團體與政黨的關係…………66
第四節理性化及其出路…………68
(一)理性化與非理性…………69
(二)科層化組織…………72
(三)理性化的出路…………77
(四)社會主義…………80
第四章馬克思與韋伯階級概念的比較…………87
第一節生產觀與市場觀的辯論…………87
第二節中間階級理論的爭議…………95
(一)韋伯階級概念的發展…………96
(二)馬克思階級概念的發展…………99
第三節中間階級:實證調查…………113
(一)紐約理工學院的調查…………115
(二)King等人對「工業管理人員」的調查…………116
(三)Zussman對「工人中間階級」的調查…………118
(四)比較…………120
第四節工人階級…………123
第五章結論…………133
圖表目錄
附圖(一)…………56
附圖(二)…………76
附圖(三)…………109
附圖(四)…………110
附圖(五)…………110		zh_TW
dc.source.uri (資料來源) http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#B2002005281en_US
dc.title (題名) 階級理論的兩大傳統-馬克思與韋伯階級概念的比較zh_TW
dc.type (資料類型) thesisen_US
dc.relation.reference (參考文獻) 參考書目
一、中文部分:
1.王振寰
1980 「韋伯『理性化』的意義及其對工具理性的批評」，思與言，18卷4期，(11):289~306。
2.王章陵
1982 「馬克思的歷史階段一一從資本主義社會到共產主義社會(二)」，共黨問題研究，8卷9期，(9):1~13。
3.布洛克曼
1987 結構主義，台北:谷風出版社。
4.列寧
1945 國家與革命，北平:解放社。
5.何忠良
1988 「青年馬克思意識型態觀的探索」，東亞季刊，19卷3期，(1):35~53。
6.李青宜
1988 阿爾杜塞爾與結構主義馬克思主義，台北:谷風出版社。
7.沈起予
1982 「馬克思的人學」，中國大陸月刊，178期，(6):52~59。
8.金子榮一
1986 韋伯的比較社會學，台北:水牛出版社。
9.周伯戡譯著
1986 社會思想的冠冕:韋伯，台北:時報出版公司。
10.帕爾金(Frank Parkin) 黃丘隆譯
1989 馬克斯﹒韋伯，台北:結構出版群。
11.馬克思
1961 路易波拿巴的霧月十八日，「馬克思恩格斯全集」(以下簡稱「馬恩全集」)第8卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965a 共產黨宣言，馬恩全集第4卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965b 哲學的貧困，馬恩全集第4卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965c 德意志意識型態，馬恩全集第3卷，北平;人民出版社。
1965d 法蘭西內戰，馬恩全集第17卷，北平;人民出版社。
1965e 哥達綱領批判，馬恩全集第19卷，北平:人民出版社。
1965f 政治經濟學批判序言，馬恩全集第13卷，北平:人民出版社。
1974 資本論第三卷，馬恩全集第25卷，北平:人民出版社。
1979 一八四四年經濟學哲學手稿，馬恩全集第42卷，北平:人民出版社。
12契波拉編
1984 歐洲經濟史(工業革命篇)II，張彬村編譯，台北:允晨文化公司。
1985 歐洲經濟史:工業社會的興起I，張彬村、林灑華譯，台北:允晨文化公司。
13.柯塞 黃瑞祺、張維安譯
1988 古典社會學理論，台北:桂冠圖書公司。
14.施路赫特(Wolfgang Schluchter) 顧忠華譯
1986 理性化與官僚化一一對韋伯的研究與詮釋，台北:聯經出版公司。
15.胡麗玲
1985 馬克思主義階級論之研究，政治大學東亞研究所碩士論文。
16.韋伯(Max Weber)
1985a 支配的類型，康樂編譯，台北:遠流出版社。
1985b 學術與政治，錢永祥編譯，台北:遠流出版社。
17.高承恕
1988 理性化與資本主義一一韋伯與韋伯之外，台北:聯經出版社。
18.徐崇溫
1985 西方馬克思主義，台北:谷風出版社。
19.陳介玄、翟本瑞、張維安
1989 韋伯論西方社會的理性化，台北:巨流圖書公司。
20.許津橋
1987 社會理論與政治實踐，台北:圓神出版社。
21.畢浩明編
1987 社會學:界限與侷限，台北:谷風出版社。
22.黃瑞祺
1980 「韋伯的弔詭」，思與言，18卷4期，(11):307~327。
23.許嘉猷
1986 社會階層化與社會流動，台北:三民書局。
24.張潤書
1976 行政學，台北:三民書局。
25.張一柱譯
1986 「共黨在西歐:沈滯不前的政黨」，中國大陸研究教學參考資料，39期，(3):86。
26.張華葆
1987 社會階層，台北:三民書局。
27.樊亢主編
1985 資本主義興衰史，北平:北京出版社。
28.Kautsky, k.(考茨基)
1980 論無產階級專政，台北:黎明文化公司。
29.Mantoux, P.周寰文譯
1976 十八世紀的產業革命，台北:中華書局。
30.Ritzer,G.馬康莊、陳信木譯
1989 社會學理論，台北:巨流圖書公司。

二、英文部分
1. Balbus, I. D .
1982 Marxism and Domination, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
2. Beetham, D.
1985 Max Weber and Theory of Modern Politics,Cambridge: Polity Press.
3. Bologh, R.W.
1984 "Max Weber and the Di1emma of Rationality" in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London : Greenwood Press. PP. 175~186.
4. Bottomore, T. ed.
1983 A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, Cambridge (U.S.A) : Harvard University Press.
5. Castoriadis, C.
1980 "Socialism and Autonomous Society," TELOS No. 43. ( spring) : 91~105 .
6. Connel, R. W.
1980 " A Critique of the Althusserian Approach to Class," Theory and Society vol. 8. No . 3.(11): 303~345.
7. Crompton, R.
1976 "Approaches to the Study of White-Collar Unionism," Sociology vo1. 10. No.3. (9) :
407~426.
8. Dow Jur, T. E.
1978 "An Analysis of Weber`s Work on Charisma,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1.(3): 83~93.
9. Eisen, A.
1978 "The Meanings & Confusions of Weberians` Rationality," British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1. (3): 57~70.
10. Form, W.
1973 "The Internal Stratification of the Working Class:System Involvement of Auto Workers in Four Countries," American Sociological Review vo1. 38. No.4. (12) : 697~711.
1983 “Sociological Research and American Working Class," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 24.NO.2. (Spring) : 163~184.
11. Giddens, A.
1981 Politics and Sociology in the Thought of Max Weber, London: The Macmillan Press LTD.
12 Girardin, Jean-Claude
1974 "On the Marxist Theory of the state," Politics and Society vo1. 4. NO.2. PP.193~223.
13. Goldman, R. & Tickamyer. A.
1984 “Status Attainment and the Commodity Form:Stratification in Historical Perspective,"American Sociologica1 Review vo1. 49. (4) : 196~209.
14. Gray, R. Q.
1975 “ Critical Note: The Political Incorporation of the Working Class," Sociology vo1. 19. No. 1. (1): 101 ~ 104.
15. Jacoby, R.
1978 “Political Economy and Class Consciousness," Theory and Society vo1. 5 . No.1. (1): 11~18.
16.Jensen-Bulter, B.
1976 “An Outline of a Weberian Analysis of Class With Particular Reference to the Middle Class and the NSDAP in Weimar Germany,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 27. No.1 .(3): 50 ~ 60.
17. King, L. & Child, J. & Pearce, S.
1980 "Class Perspections and Social Identification of Industrial Supervisors," Sociology
vol. 14. No.3. (8): 563 ~599.
18. Levine, R.F. & Lembcke, J. ed.
1987 Recapturing Marxism: An Appraisa1 of Recent Trends in Sociological Theory, New York:Praeger Publishers.
19. Lopreato, J. & Hazelrigg, L.E.
1972 Class, Conflict, and Mobility, San Francisco:Chandler Publishing Co.
20. Miliband, R .
1978 Marxism and Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
21. McLoughlin, I.
1982 "Misunderstanding the New Middle Class,"Sociology vol. 16. No.4. (11): 586~590.
22. Mommsen, Wolfgang J.
1985 “Capitalism and Socialism: Weber`s Dialogue With Marx," in A Weber-Marx Dialogue, ed. by R. J. Antonio & R.M. Glassman,台北:原學出版社。PP. 234~256.
23. Murphy, R.
1984 “The Structure of Closure: A Critique and Development of the Theories of Weber, Collins,and Parkin," British Journal of Sociology vol 35. No .4. (12): 547~567.
1986 "Weberian Closure Theory:A Contribution to the Ongoing Assessment," British Journal of Sociology vol. 37. NO.1. (3): 21~41.
24. Murvar, V.
1984 “Epilogue: Max Weber and the Two Nonrevolut-ionry Events in Russia 1917: Scientific Achievement or Prophetic Failures? ,"in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R. M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London: Greenwood Press. PP.237~272.
25. Ollman, B.
1972 “Towards Class Consciousness Next Time: Marx and The Working Class," Politics and Society vol. 3. No. 1. (Fall) : 1~24.
26. Parkin, F.
1982 “Social Closure and Class Formation," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed. by A. Giddens and D. Held, California : California University.PP.175~184.
27. Przeworski, A.
1977 "Proletariat into a Class: The Process of Class Formation from Karl Kautsky`s The
Class Struggle to Recent Controversies,"Politics and Society vol. 7. No. 4. PP. 343~401.
28. Robinson, R.V. & Kelley, J.
1979 “Class as Conceived by Marx & Dahrendorf :Effects On Income Inequality and Politics in the United States & Great Britain," American Sociological Review vol. 44. No.1. (2) : 38~57 .
29. Scruton, R.
1985 Thinkers of the New Left, 台北:唐山出版社。
30. Swatos, W.H.
1984 "Revolution and Charisma in a Rationalized World: Weber Revisited and Extend," in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London :Greenwood Press.PP.201~215.
31 Tanner, J. & Cockerrill, R.
1986 "In Search of Working-Class Ideology: A Test of Two Perspectives," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 27. No.3. (9) : 389~402.
32 Taylor, S.
1978 “Parkin`s Theory of Working Class Conservation: Two Hypotheses Investigated," The Sociological Review vol. 26. No.4. (11): 827~842.
33 Tones, Bryn
1975 "Max Weber and The Concept of Social Class," The Sociological Review vol. 23. NO.4. (11) :729~759.
34 Va11as, S.
1987 "White-Collar Proletarians ?The structure of Clerical Work and Levels of Class Consciousness,"The Sociological Quarterly vol. 28. NO.4. (12): 523~540.
35 Weber, M.
1978 Weber: Selections in Translation, tran. By E. Matthews, ed . by W.G. Runciman, London:Cambridge University Press.
1982 "Selections from Economy and Society vol. 1 & vo1. 2. & Genera1 Economy History," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed . by A. Giddens & D. Held,California:California University.PP. 60~86.
1985 Economy and Society, 台北:宗青圖書公司。
36 Wenger, M. G .
1987 .. Class Closure and The Historical/ Structure Limits of Marx-Weber Convergence," in The Marx-Weber Debate ed. by N. Wiley, California:SAGE Publications LTD.PP.43~64.
37 Wiley, N. ed.
1987 The Marx-Weber Debate, London: SAGE Publications LTD.
38 Wright, E.O.
1976 "Class Boundaries in Advanced Capitalist Societies," New Left Review No. 98. (6): 3~41.
1980 “Varieties of Marxist Conceptions of Class Structure, " Po1itics and Society vol. 9. No. 3. PP. 323~370.
39 Zussman, R .
1984 “The Middle Levels: Engineers and the Working Middle Class," Politics and Society vol. 13 . No.3. PP. 217~237.		zh_TW