Publications-Theses
Article View/Open
Publication Export
-
Google ScholarTM
NCCU Library
Citation Infomation
Related Publications in TAIR
題名 階級理論的兩大傳統-馬克思與韋伯階級概念的比較 作者 詹政道 貢獻者 顧忠華
詹政道日期 1990
1989上傳時間 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8) 參考文獻 參考書目一、中文部分:1.王振寰1980 「韋伯『理性化』的意義及其對工具理性的批評」,思與言,18卷4期,(11):289~306。2.王章陵1982 「馬克思的歷史階段一一從資本主義社會到共產主義社會(二)」,共黨問題研究,8卷9期,(9):1~13。3.布洛克曼1987 結構主義,台北:谷風出版社。4.列寧1945 國家與革命,北平:解放社。5.何忠良1988 「青年馬克思意識型態觀的探索」,東亞季刊,19卷3期,(1):35~53。6.李青宜1988 阿爾杜塞爾與結構主義馬克思主義,台北:谷風出版社。7.沈起予1982 「馬克思的人學」,中國大陸月刊,178期,(6):52~59。8.金子榮一1986 韋伯的比較社會學,台北:水牛出版社。9.周伯戡譯著1986 社會思想的冠冕:韋伯,台北:時報出版公司。10.帕爾金(Frank Parkin) 黃丘隆譯1989 馬克斯﹒韋伯,台北:結構出版群。11.馬克思1961 路易波拿巴的霧月十八日,「馬克思恩格斯全集」(以下簡稱「馬恩全集」)第8卷,北平:人民出版社。1965a 共產黨宣言,馬恩全集第4卷,北平:人民出版社。1965b 哲學的貧困,馬恩全集第4卷,北平:人民出版社。1965c 德意志意識型態,馬恩全集第3卷,北平;人民出版社。1965d 法蘭西內戰,馬恩全集第17卷,北平;人民出版社。1965e 哥達綱領批判,馬恩全集第19卷,北平:人民出版社。1965f 政治經濟學批判序言,馬恩全集第13卷,北平:人民出版社。1974 資本論第三卷,馬恩全集第25卷,北平:人民出版社。1979 一八四四年經濟學哲學手稿,馬恩全集第42卷,北平:人民出版社。12契波拉編1984 歐洲經濟史(工業革命篇)II,張彬村編譯,台北:允晨文化公司。1985 歐洲經濟史:工業社會的興起I,張彬村、林灑華譯,台北:允晨文化公司。13.柯塞 黃瑞祺、張維安譯1988 古典社會學理論,台北:桂冠圖書公司。14.施路赫特(Wolfgang Schluchter) 顧忠華譯1986 理性化與官僚化一一對韋伯的研究與詮釋,台北:聯經出版公司。15.胡麗玲1985 馬克思主義階級論之研究,政治大學東亞研究所碩士論文。16.韋伯(Max Weber)1985a 支配的類型,康樂編譯,台北:遠流出版社。1985b 學術與政治,錢永祥編譯,台北:遠流出版社。17.高承恕1988 理性化與資本主義一一韋伯與韋伯之外,台北:聯經出版社。18.徐崇溫1985 西方馬克思主義,台北:谷風出版社。19.陳介玄、翟本瑞、張維安1989 韋伯論西方社會的理性化,台北:巨流圖書公司。20.許津橋1987 社會理論與政治實踐,台北:圓神出版社。21.畢浩明編1987 社會學:界限與侷限,台北:谷風出版社。22.黃瑞祺1980 「韋伯的弔詭」,思與言,18卷4期,(11):307~327。23.許嘉猷1986 社會階層化與社會流動,台北:三民書局。24.張潤書1976 行政學,台北:三民書局。25.張一柱譯1986 「共黨在西歐:沈滯不前的政黨」,中國大陸研究教學參考資料,39期,(3):86。26.張華葆1987 社會階層,台北:三民書局。27.樊亢主編1985 資本主義興衰史,北平:北京出版社。28.Kautsky, k.(考茨基)1980 論無產階級專政,台北:黎明文化公司。29.Mantoux, P.周寰文譯1976 十八世紀的產業革命,台北:中華書局。30.Ritzer,G.馬康莊、陳信木譯1989 社會學理論,台北:巨流圖書公司。二、英文部分1. Balbus, I. D .1982 Marxism and Domination, Princeton: Princeton University Press.2. Beetham, D.1985 Max Weber and Theory of Modern Politics,Cambridge: Polity Press.3. Bologh, R.W.1984 "Max Weber and the Di1emma of Rationality" in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London : Greenwood Press. PP. 175~186.4. Bottomore, T. ed.1983 A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, Cambridge (U.S.A) : Harvard University Press.5. Castoriadis, C.1980 "Socialism and Autonomous Society," TELOS No. 43. ( spring) : 91~105 .6. Connel, R. W.1980 " A Critique of the Althusserian Approach to Class," Theory and Society vol. 8. No . 3.(11): 303~345.7. Crompton, R.1976 "Approaches to the Study of White-Collar Unionism," Sociology vo1. 10. No.3. (9) :407~426.8. Dow Jur, T. E.1978 "An Analysis of Weber`s Work on Charisma,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1.(3): 83~93.9. Eisen, A.1978 "The Meanings & Confusions of Weberians` Rationality," British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1. (3): 57~70.10. Form, W.1973 "The Internal Stratification of the Working Class:System Involvement of Auto Workers in Four Countries," American Sociological Review vo1. 38. No.4. (12) : 697~711.1983 “Sociological Research and American Working Class," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 24.NO.2. (Spring) : 163~184.11. Giddens, A.1981 Politics and Sociology in the Thought of Max Weber, London: The Macmillan Press LTD.12 Girardin, Jean-Claude1974 "On the Marxist Theory of the state," Politics and Society vo1. 4. NO.2. PP.193~223.13. Goldman, R. & Tickamyer. A.1984 “Status Attainment and the Commodity Form:Stratification in Historical Perspective,"American Sociologica1 Review vo1. 49. (4) : 196~209.14. Gray, R. Q.1975 “ Critical Note: The Political Incorporation of the Working Class," Sociology vo1. 19. No. 1. (1): 101 ~ 104.15. Jacoby, R.1978 “Political Economy and Class Consciousness," Theory and Society vo1. 5 . No.1. (1): 11~18.16.Jensen-Bulter, B.1976 “An Outline of a Weberian Analysis of Class With Particular Reference to the Middle Class and the NSDAP in Weimar Germany,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 27. No.1 .(3): 50 ~ 60.17. King, L. & Child, J. & Pearce, S.1980 "Class Perspections and Social Identification of Industrial Supervisors," Sociologyvol. 14. No.3. (8): 563 ~599.18. Levine, R.F. & Lembcke, J. ed.1987 Recapturing Marxism: An Appraisa1 of Recent Trends in Sociological Theory, New York:Praeger Publishers.19. Lopreato, J. & Hazelrigg, L.E.1972 Class, Conflict, and Mobility, San Francisco:Chandler Publishing Co.20. Miliband, R .1978 Marxism and Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.21. McLoughlin, I.1982 "Misunderstanding the New Middle Class,"Sociology vol. 16. No.4. (11): 586~590.22. Mommsen, Wolfgang J.1985 “Capitalism and Socialism: Weber`s Dialogue With Marx," in A Weber-Marx Dialogue, ed. by R. J. Antonio & R.M. Glassman,台北:原學出版社。PP. 234~256.23. Murphy, R.1984 “The Structure of Closure: A Critique and Development of the Theories of Weber, Collins,and Parkin," British Journal of Sociology vol 35. No .4. (12): 547~567.1986 "Weberian Closure Theory:A Contribution to the Ongoing Assessment," British Journal of Sociology vol. 37. NO.1. (3): 21~41.24. Murvar, V.1984 “Epilogue: Max Weber and the Two Nonrevolut-ionry Events in Russia 1917: Scientific Achievement or Prophetic Failures? ,"in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R. M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London: Greenwood Press. PP.237~272.25. Ollman, B.1972 “Towards Class Consciousness Next Time: Marx and The Working Class," Politics and Society vol. 3. No. 1. (Fall) : 1~24.26. Parkin, F.1982 “Social Closure and Class Formation," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed. by A. Giddens and D. Held, California : California University.PP.175~184.27. Przeworski, A.1977 "Proletariat into a Class: The Process of Class Formation from Karl Kautsky`s TheClass Struggle to Recent Controversies,"Politics and Society vol. 7. No. 4. PP. 343~401.28. Robinson, R.V. & Kelley, J.1979 “Class as Conceived by Marx & Dahrendorf :Effects On Income Inequality and Politics in the United States & Great Britain," American Sociological Review vol. 44. No.1. (2) : 38~57 .29. Scruton, R.1985 Thinkers of the New Left, 台北:唐山出版社。30. Swatos, W.H.1984 "Revolution and Charisma in a Rationalized World: Weber Revisited and Extend," in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London :Greenwood Press.PP.201~215.31 Tanner, J. & Cockerrill, R.1986 "In Search of Working-Class Ideology: A Test of Two Perspectives," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 27. No.3. (9) : 389~402.32 Taylor, S.1978 “Parkin`s Theory of Working Class Conservation: Two Hypotheses Investigated," The Sociological Review vol. 26. No.4. (11): 827~842.33 Tones, Bryn1975 "Max Weber and The Concept of Social Class," The Sociological Review vol. 23. NO.4. (11) :729~759.34 Va11as, S.1987 "White-Collar Proletarians ?The structure of Clerical Work and Levels of Class Consciousness,"The Sociological Quarterly vol. 28. NO.4. (12): 523~540.35 Weber, M.1978 Weber: Selections in Translation, tran. By E. Matthews, ed . by W.G. Runciman, London:Cambridge University Press.1982 "Selections from Economy and Society vol. 1 & vo1. 2. & Genera1 Economy History," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed . by A. Giddens & D. Held,California:California University.PP. 60~86.1985 Economy and Society, 台北:宗青圖書公司。36 Wenger, M. G .1987 .. Class Closure and The Historical/ Structure Limits of Marx-Weber Convergence," in The Marx-Weber Debate ed. by N. Wiley, California:SAGE Publications LTD.PP.43~64.37 Wiley, N. ed.1987 The Marx-Weber Debate, London: SAGE Publications LTD.38 Wright, E.O.1976 "Class Boundaries in Advanced Capitalist Societies," New Left Review No. 98. (6): 3~41.1980 “Varieties of Marxist Conceptions of Class Structure, " Po1itics and Society vol. 9. No. 3. PP. 323~370.39 Zussman, R .1984 “The Middle Levels: Engineers and the Working Middle Class," Politics and Society vol. 13 . No.3. PP. 217~237. 描述 碩士
國立政治大學
東亞研究所資料來源 http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#B2002005281 資料類型 thesis dc.contributor.advisor 顧忠華 zh_TW dc.contributor.author (Authors) 詹政道 zh_TW dc.creator (作者) 詹政道 zh_TW dc.date (日期) 1990 en_US dc.date (日期) 1989 en_US dc.date.accessioned 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8) - dc.date.available 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8) - dc.date.issued (上傳時間) 3-May-2016 14:23:49 (UTC+8) - dc.identifier (Other Identifiers) B2002005281 en_US dc.identifier.uri (URI) http://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/90336 - dc.description (描述) 碩士 zh_TW dc.description (描述) 國立政治大學 zh_TW dc.description (描述) 東亞研究所 zh_TW dc.description.tableofcontents 目錄第一章導論…………1第一節階級的語源…………1第二節資本主義經濟結構的變遷…………3第二章馬克思的階級概念…………7第一節社會的階級分析…………7(一)階級劃分的標準與「中間階級」…………7(二)經理階級…………15第二節宰制的面向…………16(一)結構性的宰制…………171.經濟結構的宰制…………172.法律、政治結構的宰制…………18(二)意識型態的宰制…………23第三節異化狀態的自覺與階級鬥爭…………24(一)鬥爭與階級意識…………24(二)階級意識發展的客觀條件…………30第四節階級的消滅…………33(一)第一階段…………34(二)最高階段…………38第三章韋伯的階級概念…………45第一節社會行動與市場…………45(一)社會行動…………45(二)市場…………47第二節階級…………48第三節社會壁壘(social exclusion)——階級、地位團體、政黨的關係…………55(一)地位團體及其與階級的關係…………57(二)階級、地位團體與政黨的關係…………66第四節理性化及其出路…………68(一)理性化與非理性…………69(二)科層化組織…………72(三)理性化的出路…………77(四)社會主義…………80第四章馬克思與韋伯階級概念的比較…………87第一節生產觀與市場觀的辯論…………87第二節中間階級理論的爭議…………95(一)韋伯階級概念的發展…………96(二)馬克思階級概念的發展…………99第三節中間階級:實證調查…………113(一)紐約理工學院的調查…………115(二)King等人對「工業管理人員」的調查…………116(三)Zussman對「工人中間階級」的調查…………118(四)比較…………120第四節工人階級…………123第五章結論…………133圖表目錄附圖(一)…………56附圖(二)…………76附圖(三)…………109附圖(四)…………110附圖(五)…………110 zh_TW dc.source.uri (資料來源) http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#B2002005281 en_US dc.title (題名) 階級理論的兩大傳統-馬克思與韋伯階級概念的比較 zh_TW dc.type (資料類型) thesis en_US dc.relation.reference (參考文獻) 參考書目一、中文部分:1.王振寰1980 「韋伯『理性化』的意義及其對工具理性的批評」,思與言,18卷4期,(11):289~306。2.王章陵1982 「馬克思的歷史階段一一從資本主義社會到共產主義社會(二)」,共黨問題研究,8卷9期,(9):1~13。3.布洛克曼1987 結構主義,台北:谷風出版社。4.列寧1945 國家與革命,北平:解放社。5.何忠良1988 「青年馬克思意識型態觀的探索」,東亞季刊,19卷3期,(1):35~53。6.李青宜1988 阿爾杜塞爾與結構主義馬克思主義,台北:谷風出版社。7.沈起予1982 「馬克思的人學」,中國大陸月刊,178期,(6):52~59。8.金子榮一1986 韋伯的比較社會學,台北:水牛出版社。9.周伯戡譯著1986 社會思想的冠冕:韋伯,台北:時報出版公司。10.帕爾金(Frank Parkin) 黃丘隆譯1989 馬克斯﹒韋伯,台北:結構出版群。11.馬克思1961 路易波拿巴的霧月十八日,「馬克思恩格斯全集」(以下簡稱「馬恩全集」)第8卷,北平:人民出版社。1965a 共產黨宣言,馬恩全集第4卷,北平:人民出版社。1965b 哲學的貧困,馬恩全集第4卷,北平:人民出版社。1965c 德意志意識型態,馬恩全集第3卷,北平;人民出版社。1965d 法蘭西內戰,馬恩全集第17卷,北平;人民出版社。1965e 哥達綱領批判,馬恩全集第19卷,北平:人民出版社。1965f 政治經濟學批判序言,馬恩全集第13卷,北平:人民出版社。1974 資本論第三卷,馬恩全集第25卷,北平:人民出版社。1979 一八四四年經濟學哲學手稿,馬恩全集第42卷,北平:人民出版社。12契波拉編1984 歐洲經濟史(工業革命篇)II,張彬村編譯,台北:允晨文化公司。1985 歐洲經濟史:工業社會的興起I,張彬村、林灑華譯,台北:允晨文化公司。13.柯塞 黃瑞祺、張維安譯1988 古典社會學理論,台北:桂冠圖書公司。14.施路赫特(Wolfgang Schluchter) 顧忠華譯1986 理性化與官僚化一一對韋伯的研究與詮釋,台北:聯經出版公司。15.胡麗玲1985 馬克思主義階級論之研究,政治大學東亞研究所碩士論文。16.韋伯(Max Weber)1985a 支配的類型,康樂編譯,台北:遠流出版社。1985b 學術與政治,錢永祥編譯,台北:遠流出版社。17.高承恕1988 理性化與資本主義一一韋伯與韋伯之外,台北:聯經出版社。18.徐崇溫1985 西方馬克思主義,台北:谷風出版社。19.陳介玄、翟本瑞、張維安1989 韋伯論西方社會的理性化,台北:巨流圖書公司。20.許津橋1987 社會理論與政治實踐,台北:圓神出版社。21.畢浩明編1987 社會學:界限與侷限,台北:谷風出版社。22.黃瑞祺1980 「韋伯的弔詭」,思與言,18卷4期,(11):307~327。23.許嘉猷1986 社會階層化與社會流動,台北:三民書局。24.張潤書1976 行政學,台北:三民書局。25.張一柱譯1986 「共黨在西歐:沈滯不前的政黨」,中國大陸研究教學參考資料,39期,(3):86。26.張華葆1987 社會階層,台北:三民書局。27.樊亢主編1985 資本主義興衰史,北平:北京出版社。28.Kautsky, k.(考茨基)1980 論無產階級專政,台北:黎明文化公司。29.Mantoux, P.周寰文譯1976 十八世紀的產業革命,台北:中華書局。30.Ritzer,G.馬康莊、陳信木譯1989 社會學理論,台北:巨流圖書公司。二、英文部分1. Balbus, I. D .1982 Marxism and Domination, Princeton: Princeton University Press.2. Beetham, D.1985 Max Weber and Theory of Modern Politics,Cambridge: Polity Press.3. Bologh, R.W.1984 "Max Weber and the Di1emma of Rationality" in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London : Greenwood Press. PP. 175~186.4. Bottomore, T. ed.1983 A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, Cambridge (U.S.A) : Harvard University Press.5. Castoriadis, C.1980 "Socialism and Autonomous Society," TELOS No. 43. ( spring) : 91~105 .6. Connel, R. W.1980 " A Critique of the Althusserian Approach to Class," Theory and Society vol. 8. No . 3.(11): 303~345.7. Crompton, R.1976 "Approaches to the Study of White-Collar Unionism," Sociology vo1. 10. No.3. (9) :407~426.8. Dow Jur, T. E.1978 "An Analysis of Weber`s Work on Charisma,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1.(3): 83~93.9. Eisen, A.1978 "The Meanings & Confusions of Weberians` Rationality," British Journal of Sociology vol. 29. No.1. (3): 57~70.10. Form, W.1973 "The Internal Stratification of the Working Class:System Involvement of Auto Workers in Four Countries," American Sociological Review vo1. 38. No.4. (12) : 697~711.1983 “Sociological Research and American Working Class," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 24.NO.2. (Spring) : 163~184.11. Giddens, A.1981 Politics and Sociology in the Thought of Max Weber, London: The Macmillan Press LTD.12 Girardin, Jean-Claude1974 "On the Marxist Theory of the state," Politics and Society vo1. 4. NO.2. PP.193~223.13. Goldman, R. & Tickamyer. A.1984 “Status Attainment and the Commodity Form:Stratification in Historical Perspective,"American Sociologica1 Review vo1. 49. (4) : 196~209.14. Gray, R. Q.1975 “ Critical Note: The Political Incorporation of the Working Class," Sociology vo1. 19. No. 1. (1): 101 ~ 104.15. Jacoby, R.1978 “Political Economy and Class Consciousness," Theory and Society vo1. 5 . No.1. (1): 11~18.16.Jensen-Bulter, B.1976 “An Outline of a Weberian Analysis of Class With Particular Reference to the Middle Class and the NSDAP in Weimar Germany,"British Journal of Sociology vol. 27. No.1 .(3): 50 ~ 60.17. King, L. & Child, J. & Pearce, S.1980 "Class Perspections and Social Identification of Industrial Supervisors," Sociologyvol. 14. No.3. (8): 563 ~599.18. Levine, R.F. & Lembcke, J. ed.1987 Recapturing Marxism: An Appraisa1 of Recent Trends in Sociological Theory, New York:Praeger Publishers.19. Lopreato, J. & Hazelrigg, L.E.1972 Class, Conflict, and Mobility, San Francisco:Chandler Publishing Co.20. Miliband, R .1978 Marxism and Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.21. McLoughlin, I.1982 "Misunderstanding the New Middle Class,"Sociology vol. 16. No.4. (11): 586~590.22. Mommsen, Wolfgang J.1985 “Capitalism and Socialism: Weber`s Dialogue With Marx," in A Weber-Marx Dialogue, ed. by R. J. Antonio & R.M. Glassman,台北:原學出版社。PP. 234~256.23. Murphy, R.1984 “The Structure of Closure: A Critique and Development of the Theories of Weber, Collins,and Parkin," British Journal of Sociology vol 35. No .4. (12): 547~567.1986 "Weberian Closure Theory:A Contribution to the Ongoing Assessment," British Journal of Sociology vol. 37. NO.1. (3): 21~41.24. Murvar, V.1984 “Epilogue: Max Weber and the Two Nonrevolut-ionry Events in Russia 1917: Scientific Achievement or Prophetic Failures? ,"in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R. M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London: Greenwood Press. PP.237~272.25. Ollman, B.1972 “Towards Class Consciousness Next Time: Marx and The Working Class," Politics and Society vol. 3. No. 1. (Fall) : 1~24.26. Parkin, F.1982 “Social Closure and Class Formation," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed. by A. Giddens and D. Held, California : California University.PP.175~184.27. Przeworski, A.1977 "Proletariat into a Class: The Process of Class Formation from Karl Kautsky`s TheClass Struggle to Recent Controversies,"Politics and Society vol. 7. No. 4. PP. 343~401.28. Robinson, R.V. & Kelley, J.1979 “Class as Conceived by Marx & Dahrendorf :Effects On Income Inequality and Politics in the United States & Great Britain," American Sociological Review vol. 44. No.1. (2) : 38~57 .29. Scruton, R.1985 Thinkers of the New Left, 台北:唐山出版社。30. Swatos, W.H.1984 "Revolution and Charisma in a Rationalized World: Weber Revisited and Extend," in Max Weber`s Political Sociology, ed. by R.M. Glassman & V. Murvar, London :Greenwood Press.PP.201~215.31 Tanner, J. & Cockerrill, R.1986 "In Search of Working-Class Ideology: A Test of Two Perspectives," The Sociological Quarterly vol. 27. No.3. (9) : 389~402.32 Taylor, S.1978 “Parkin`s Theory of Working Class Conservation: Two Hypotheses Investigated," The Sociological Review vol. 26. No.4. (11): 827~842.33 Tones, Bryn1975 "Max Weber and The Concept of Social Class," The Sociological Review vol. 23. NO.4. (11) :729~759.34 Va11as, S.1987 "White-Collar Proletarians ?The structure of Clerical Work and Levels of Class Consciousness,"The Sociological Quarterly vol. 28. NO.4. (12): 523~540.35 Weber, M.1978 Weber: Selections in Translation, tran. By E. Matthews, ed . by W.G. Runciman, London:Cambridge University Press.1982 "Selections from Economy and Society vol. 1 & vo1. 2. & Genera1 Economy History," in Class, Power, and Conflict, ed . by A. Giddens & D. Held,California:California University.PP. 60~86.1985 Economy and Society, 台北:宗青圖書公司。36 Wenger, M. G .1987 .. Class Closure and The Historical/ Structure Limits of Marx-Weber Convergence," in The Marx-Weber Debate ed. by N. Wiley, California:SAGE Publications LTD.PP.43~64.37 Wiley, N. ed.1987 The Marx-Weber Debate, London: SAGE Publications LTD.38 Wright, E.O.1976 "Class Boundaries in Advanced Capitalist Societies," New Left Review No. 98. (6): 3~41.1980 “Varieties of Marxist Conceptions of Class Structure, " Po1itics and Society vol. 9. No. 3. PP. 323~370.39 Zussman, R .1984 “The Middle Levels: Engineers and the Working Middle Class," Politics and Society vol. 13 . No.3. PP. 217~237. zh_TW