學術產出-NSC Projects

Article View/Open

Publication Export

Google ScholarTM

政大圖書館

Citation Infomation

  • No doi shows Citation Infomation
題名 賣空與選擇權交易的替代關係
作者 周冠男
貢獻者 財務管理學系
關鍵詞 訊息交易;選擇權交易;試驗計畫;賣空;替代效果
Information Trading; Option Trading; Pilot Program; Short-sales; Substitutability
日期 2014
上傳時間 24-Jan-2018 14:54:23 (UTC+8)
摘要 本研究探討美國證券管理委員會於2005 年至2007 年間採取的賣空限制放寬實驗,分析實驗前後選擇權市場的交易量及資訊含量的變化,以推論選擇權交易與賣空交易間是否存在替代效果。本文的研究結果發現,當股票市場的賣空限制放鬆後:(1)選擇權賣權的交易量顯著下降,(2)相較於買權,賣權的價格壓力顯著下降;以往賣權價格高於買權價格的現象趨緩,(3)價格偏離買權/賣權平價的機率下降,(4)選擇權的訊息含量下降。總結而言,本研究發現,當股票市場存在賣空限制時,購買股票選擇權的賣權是交易壞消息的替代交易策略之一,股票市場與選擇權市場存在替代關係。此外,股票市場的賣空限制會導致賣權的買壓大於買權的買壓,使兩者之間的價格失衡,導致價格偏離買權/賣權平價。近期關於賣空交易與選擇權交易之間替代效果的研究,多以2008 年金融危機時,各國實施的禁止賣空交易作為研究事件。但於2008 年金融危機時,各國除了禁止賣空交易,同時實施其他穩定市場措施,因此無法看出單一事件所帶來的影響。在金融危機期間,市場的過度波動與不確定性,亦可能改變投資人的風險趨避態度及投資行為。最後,金融危機期間實施的賣空限制侷限於金融類股,存在研究樣本過度集中的問題。本文所使用的事件可有效克服近期相關研究的缺失。
We study the substitutability of the stock and the option market trading surrounding a temporary suspension of short-sale constraints introduced by Reg SHO from 2005 to 2007. The Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) designated a set of pilot securities for the suspension, i.e., the “Pilot Program.” We find a significant decrease in put volume for the pilot stocks. The pilot stock put prices decrease significantly relative to the pilot stock call prices after Reg SHO. We also find that information content of the option trading decreases significantly. These results suggest that the option market is a substitute to the stock market, because the short-sale constraints relaxation allows traders to switch part of their trading demand to the stock market. Most current studies examine the effect of short sale constraints on the option markets with short sale bans during the 2008 financial crisis. However, the 2008 short sale bans were implemented as a response to unusual market conditions and only financial stocks are subject to such bans. Trader behaviors are likely to change during extreme market events, which would interfere with the effect of short sale bans. The market is relatively stable during the Pilot Program and the pilot stocks span a much wider range of industries. We believe that the Pilot Program would better facilitate the examination of the suitability of derivative trading and stock short sales.
關聯 執行起迄:2014/08/01~2015/07/31
103-2410-H-004-028
資料類型 report
dc.contributor 財務管理學系zh_Tw
dc.creator (作者) 周冠男zh_TW
dc.date (日期) 2014en_US
dc.date.accessioned 24-Jan-2018 14:54:23 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.available 24-Jan-2018 14:54:23 (UTC+8)-
dc.date.issued (上傳時間) 24-Jan-2018 14:54:23 (UTC+8)-
dc.identifier.uri (URI) http://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/115622-
dc.description.abstract (摘要) 本研究探討美國證券管理委員會於2005 年至2007 年間採取的賣空限制放寬實驗,分析實驗前後選擇權市場的交易量及資訊含量的變化,以推論選擇權交易與賣空交易間是否存在替代效果。本文的研究結果發現,當股票市場的賣空限制放鬆後:(1)選擇權賣權的交易量顯著下降,(2)相較於買權,賣權的價格壓力顯著下降;以往賣權價格高於買權價格的現象趨緩,(3)價格偏離買權/賣權平價的機率下降,(4)選擇權的訊息含量下降。總結而言,本研究發現,當股票市場存在賣空限制時,購買股票選擇權的賣權是交易壞消息的替代交易策略之一,股票市場與選擇權市場存在替代關係。此外,股票市場的賣空限制會導致賣權的買壓大於買權的買壓,使兩者之間的價格失衡,導致價格偏離買權/賣權平價。近期關於賣空交易與選擇權交易之間替代效果的研究,多以2008 年金融危機時,各國實施的禁止賣空交易作為研究事件。但於2008 年金融危機時,各國除了禁止賣空交易,同時實施其他穩定市場措施,因此無法看出單一事件所帶來的影響。在金融危機期間,市場的過度波動與不確定性,亦可能改變投資人的風險趨避態度及投資行為。最後,金融危機期間實施的賣空限制侷限於金融類股,存在研究樣本過度集中的問題。本文所使用的事件可有效克服近期相關研究的缺失。zh_TW
dc.description.abstract (摘要) We study the substitutability of the stock and the option market trading surrounding a temporary suspension of short-sale constraints introduced by Reg SHO from 2005 to 2007. The Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) designated a set of pilot securities for the suspension, i.e., the “Pilot Program.” We find a significant decrease in put volume for the pilot stocks. The pilot stock put prices decrease significantly relative to the pilot stock call prices after Reg SHO. We also find that information content of the option trading decreases significantly. These results suggest that the option market is a substitute to the stock market, because the short-sale constraints relaxation allows traders to switch part of their trading demand to the stock market. Most current studies examine the effect of short sale constraints on the option markets with short sale bans during the 2008 financial crisis. However, the 2008 short sale bans were implemented as a response to unusual market conditions and only financial stocks are subject to such bans. Trader behaviors are likely to change during extreme market events, which would interfere with the effect of short sale bans. The market is relatively stable during the Pilot Program and the pilot stocks span a much wider range of industries. We believe that the Pilot Program would better facilitate the examination of the suitability of derivative trading and stock short sales.en_US
dc.format.extent 538323 bytes-
dc.format.mimetype application/pdf-
dc.relation (關聯) 執行起迄:2014/08/01~2015/07/31zh_TW
dc.relation (關聯) 103-2410-H-004-028zh_TW
dc.subject (關鍵詞) 訊息交易;選擇權交易;試驗計畫;賣空;替代效果zh_TW
dc.subject (關鍵詞) Information Trading; Option Trading; Pilot Program; Short-sales; Substitutabilityen_US
dc.title (題名) 賣空與選擇權交易的替代關係_TW
dc.type (資料類型) report